Rank the resorts you've stayed at!

[johnsonet]

My hotel snob DD (age 8) says:
#1 GF
#2 WL
#3 BWI CL
#4 AKL CL
#5 Polynesian

I say:
#1 AKL CL
#2 Poly
#3 GF
#4 WL
#5 BWI CL
#6 Contemporary
I've never been unhappy with a Disney resort; I ranked WL above BWI CL only b/c I found the WL "atmosphere" and magic to be amazing

 

[TinkerBelle_325]

1. Coronado Springs
2. Wilderness Lodge
3. Caribbean Beach
4. Yacht Club Concierge
5. Dixie Landings (now Port Orleans Riverside)

 

[pouncingpluto]

1. AKL
2. Contemporary
3. Beach Club
4. Coronado Springs
5. Polynesian
6. Port Orleans French Quarter
7. Carribean Beach
8. Port Orleans Riverside
9. All Star Music
10. Fort Wilderness (tent camping)

 

[ampooh]

Since the Yacht and Beach Club are basically one why did you rank them apart? We always stay on the Beach Club side adn love it. This year we are planning(I say planning because I'm getting cold feet) to stay at the BWI. If you love the BC which woulf you think is best? YC or BWI?

All input is appreciated

 

[wer14631]

1. AKL
2. GF
3. WL
4. Dolphin

 

[Boomdocker]

1 DCL
2 AKL
3 DL
4 POFQ
5 CB
6 AS Sports

We liked them all but I think we may have been spoilt by the deluxe resorts although we found the moderates ideal and just as enjoyable. Prefer the pace, ambience and atmosphere at AKL.

 

[Tigger By The Tail]

1) All Star Sport

2)All Star Movie

3) All Star Music

4) Pop Century

5) Dixie Landing

6) Villa Treehouses ( I think that's what they were called)

 

[ILoveWDW2003]

pls delete

 

[ILoveWDW2003]

1. AKL once - going back in June!
2. WL once - going back in December!
3. All-Star Music
4. All-Star Movies
5. CBR (twice) - would go back, but only if I paid for preferred room, and I would rather spend that money on AKL or WL!

 

[AllisonG]

1-PolyCon & AKLCon
2-Wl, VWL & FTWcabins
3-CBR
4-POR

 

[CindysGusGus]

1. Akl
2.pofq
3.wl
4.csr
5.por
6.asmo

 

[tinkerbee]

1. OKW
2. POR
3. Fort Wilderness Cabins
4. ASMo
5. WL
6. ASMu

Boy I need to stay at more resorts!!

 

[pic22]

1. AKL
2. Poly
3. Swan
4. ASMus
5. OKW

Will probably change soon as we are trying either BCV or BWV and CBR in late November.

 

[glewis1123]

AKL
WLV
POLY
BWV (No one in my family liked it)

Heading to BCV on May 2 for a week - so my list my change - we'll see

 

[BadgerBruce]

1.Yacht Club
2.Boardwalk Villas
3.Coronado Springs
4.Swan
5.Dolphin
6.Dixie Landings
7.Beach Club
8.Port Orleans French Quarter

I would happily return to any of them!

 

[LVSWL]

1.Wilderness Lodge
2.Wilderness Lodge Villas
3.Beach Club Villas
4.Boardwalk Villas
5.Old Key West
6.Polynesian
7.Port Orleans French Quarter & Riverside
8.Contemporary
9.Coronado Springs(won't go back)
10.Animal Kingdom Lodge(won't go back) had a non-smoking savannah room twice, with smokers next door each time, the view is not worth it to us

 

[mommykds]

Mine are

1-Caribbean Beach - great room, great service

2-AS Movies -Toy story - big hit with my kids

3-Poly - dark, damp, rude CM's...wouldn't go back

4-AS Music - can't go back cause we are five now.

 

[disneybride96]

#1- Yacht Club Concierge
#2- Board Walk VIillas
#3- Shades of Green
#4- All Star Sports

 

[magsmom]

Mine are
1. WL (Best overall)
POFQ (Best value for paying cash)
3. CR
4. BCV
5. CBR

I would return to all of them. They were all wonderful in different respects.

My goal is to eventually stay at all of them. I get to add at least 4 more stays through the end of the year.