Can only speak for Netflix, which we use. We love it. It is so easy just to pop them in your mailbox when you are done, and to keep them as long as you want. We have used it for about 6 months. We have found lots of older titles for the kids, and many many indie films which are not available in our local rentals. It is possible that we might stop for a while as spring heads in but to get us through the winter, it works for us. We really do not go out to the movies much, as it adds up with 5 of us. 18.99 monthly unlimited. We typically rent about 9-10 monthly (due to turnaround times) so that is around 2 bucks a rental. Considering locals are $4.19 for a DVD, we are happy, especially with the late fees, that we invariably have sometimes.