We were just there last night. Food for 4 was delivered on a smallish plate: 1 small piece of fish over rice, 4 small slices of steak, 4 slices of turkey over a small portion of mashed potatoes, vegetable was swiss chard.
It was good, although steak and turkey were a bit well-done. They benefitted from the accompanying sauces (which we got on the side). You can get as much as you want, but you must reorder each time and that takes awhile.
Salad was really good, but they served just barely enough for 3 people (my one son did not eat any). We are not huge eaters, and I thought they were a bit skimpy with the food, esp. @ $38.99pp. Dessert was good also, although it was a smallish serving for 4.
We had an excellent server (Barry) who was very attentive and refilled drinks and food promptly (still took us 1 1/2 hours for dinner). I can see how having a poor server would severely impact one's experience as you really need them to refill your food fairly promptly.
Personally, although I thought the food was fine and our server was excellent, I would not do this meal again at this price. Disney found my limit.