Susy,
You would think it would make Disney happy, wouldn't you

?
Here's a suggestion - could you split your trip and do both plans?
We're planning to do this in Nov. - stay the 7/5 deal Silver at POR then switching to Plat. at the Poly for 3 nights just to do the extras we really want with the Platinum and still do it within our budget. I think you have to stay at least 3 nights per plan however.
Since you've recently stayed Platinum, would you mind answering a few questions about that plan?
1) You said you use points for meals - do they differentiate between the "snacks" and the meals? For instance, with the Gold Plan you get 3 points per day to use however. So with Platinum you get 4? I was just confused as to how that would work, and we'll be splitting ours up over 4 full days (staying at POP, room-only on our last night).
2) Did you do the spa treatment? To sound unedumacated

what is a Swedish massage? DH and I were going to try that, do they let you in the same room like the couples massage or are you in separate rooms?
3) Where is the preferred seating for Fantasmic and is it worth it? e.g. did you have to show up really early to get seated or just a few minutes prior?
4) How does the pre-arrival itenerary planning work? Do you get some kind of sheet to fill out or is it all done over the phone? How far out do they contact you?
5) If you choose an Illuminations cruise, you may have to share the boat, right? Did you do the Illuminations or Wishes cruise?
Sorry for so many questions - lol!!! Any help would be greatly appreciated; we're both really excited about our trip and I haven't been able to find the answers to these questions yet

Thank you!!!!!!!!!!