We've stayed at:
BWV - 2000, 2001 **** (great location, spacious rooms)
CR - 2000 ** (least favorite Disney resort, but would be willing to try it again now that they have refurbished the rooms)
Hilton Downtown Disney - 2000 * (just not quite the same as staying on property)
Dolphin - 2000, 2004, 2006 *** (cheapest hotel in the Boardwalk area, "heavenly" beds)
WLV - 2000 *** (beautiful resort, especially at Christmas time)
BC - 2001 **** (closest resort to Epcot, our favorite park)
AKL Concierge - 2001, 2002 **** (great concierge, beautiful resort)
Poly - 2001, 2003, 2006, Nov. 2007 ***** (our favorite resort, just wish it was closer to Epcot)
BWI - 2002 *** (great location, otherwise nothing special)
GF - 2002 *** (beautiful resort but IMO not worth the extra $$$)
BCV - 2003 **** (villas are great, and again love being close to Epcot)
POR AB - 2004 *** (pretty resort, rooms felt really small compared to DeLuxes and villas)
WL - 2006 **** (beautiful resort, rooms okay but that was before they were refurbished)
YC - Nov. 2007 We're going to do a split stay here along with the Poly.