I voted for POR. Walking "home" to those mansions makes you feel like you are staying at a Deluxe. JMO.
While we were staying at Magnolia bend, some of our friends were put in the Alligator Buyou. They weren't to hapy about this. Don't know if it was because they were too far away from us, or because they didn't like their room. The wife of the couple did mention that she didn't care for the theming of the room, but didn't bother to ask for a change of room. The theming is "back woods" not very romantic. IMO But these are the only buildings that fit a family of 5. I guess it depends on what your intentions are. I would not book it for a romantic trip, but if you are nature lovers, you may like it. To each's own I guess! No matter what you choose, you will have a great stay. They are all really great resorts. With that said, POFQ is a little smaller and easier to get around.