I like pointy toes! And I am not one who follows trends at the drop of a hat, I like the basics and classic looks. I agree w/ Oogie boogie, they create a nice line with your legs, and can make even jeans look dressy. I think the key is to wear pointy toes that are not too long (so not as narrow) and to wear a heel that is not so high. I found some great ones that are comfortable, don't have the "witch" look toe point. They have the tiniest little heel, but are basically flats. From Aldo (love that store!), very comfy.
Don't like round toes, make my feet look funny and I don't think they're very cute. Saw the People magazine section, and although those ladies are all beautiful, I thought the shoes were icky even if they did match!
Love square toes, and althought right now they aren't as "in" as pointy toes, they're still a popular/common style. So no worries, square to lovers!