please ignore

As is natural we humans tend to get defensive when we are attacked, belittled, or if someone is just being mean. Keep your chin up Peacefulgirl! It will all work out in the end!
 
peacefulgirl said:
And please stop with the no food on the table thing... obviously we are eating, maybe not steak and tips, but we are making it. Do you recall me saying I have not one late bill or not one mark on our credit? I have been living paycheck to paycheck my whole life, this is how I am where I am. Last year was the start of change, this year we will take it much further. It is all about LEARNING NEW WAYS.


You said that you were $40 short per month before gas and groceries.

That is a lack of being able to put food on the table. We are assuming you are using credit to make up the difference.
 
peacefulgirl said:
Are you serious? You think I can't feed us? I said:



OK, this was what it looked like ON PAPER for that month at that moment! Now, I didn't say this is how every month is for us. What it means is "the other things that happen" are causing a big problem. Makes sense too! If the car didn't need repair and a dentist visit needed at the same time in this month, then we wouldn't be short. Not having money aside for these is ONE problem that I can tackle.

I wouldn't take any money to pay this off, pain is what makes us grow. I wouldn't trade this lesson for anything thank you.

So are you short or are you not?

Serious tip: You need to average over a several month to a year period--presenting a budget of one month is not an accurate representation of the big picture which obviously we are missing.
 

peacefulgirl said:
I am not in a postition to run out and put most of these idea in action today. That would be making a decision without knowing what our goals are.

What don't you get about learning and gathering information? This is how I tackle EVERYTHING I am eager to learn. I wont read 1 book, I'll read as much as I can.]
You said you wanted to change your financial situation. You said you want to stop living paycheck to paycheck. I thought that was the goal.

If that's true, you need to start NOW. There is no "perfect plan" for your finances; it's always going to be a work in progress. You don't need to read a book to decide to slash your grocery bill. You don't need to sit and think about whether you should disconnect the cable TV. You don't need time to ponder whether going out to dinner on your last $20 is a good idea.

Plain and simple, you're making excuses to avoid starting a process that will not be completely pleasant. You had time to check up on the price of APs because you WANTED to do that; you can fit in time to decide what can be cut first, if you want to do it. You need to choose 1-2 things TODAY that you can do to save money. Next week choose another 1-2 things, and stick to them. You will never find a convenient day to put EVERYTHING into place. It just won't happen.

You're like a dieter who wants to lose weight . . . but she can't start now because she's having company this weekend and she wants to cook lasagna . . . she might as well not start at the beginning of next week because she's going out with her friends to lunch on Tuesday, and she knows she'll blow it then . . . in fact, there's no use starting this month at all since the family's going on vacation the last week of the month. This type of person will never lose weight because she'll never say, "TODAY is the day that I begin."

There's never a good time to start something unpleasant, so roll up your sleeves and do it now. Dreading something is always worse than just getting it over with.
peacefulgirl said:
Seems to me that you, like others here, cant relate because you haven't been where I am.]
What makes you think other people have not been in the black hole of paycheck to paycheck? Many of us have been there; we chose to get out. Seriously, you CAN do it, but you have to start right away. Every day that you wait and plan, your debt is growing, and it's one more day that you don't have a sense of financial security.

I suspect you might be a perfectionist. Many perfectionists won't begin a project because they fear they might not do it "just right". Guess what: you won't do this "just right" every day -- especially not in the beginning. But you also won't improve your financial skills until you jump in and get started. Once you do, you'll start to see improvement quickly.
 
peacefulgirl said:
My DH makes 6 figures ???? :cool1: HUH ??? See, you don't know what you are talking about!!!! THAT IS NOT TRUE !

Actually--we theorize that your combined income is 6 figures.

You provided stats....and the famous formula is WP/100*X=Y


WP stands for what percentage====4%

Y stands for what you get remaining===$400 (you stated that trimming off 4% contribution yielded this amount).

Plug the #'s and you get: X which would be your rough estimate monthly income. Which is a 6 figure #. Probably not your take home--but it is definitely a 6 month figure.

Regardless--your income is your business--how you wish to make do, get by, stretch it to afford basic necessities on up to the ladder becomes our business in a sense when you plea for help and either choose not to listen--or listen take 2 trips to Disney and come back 9 months later with another plea for help.

This is why several of us are upset. We are trying to help you and you come across as very defensive.

"Try this"
"Well I did, well we can't, well we don't do that anyway, well I'm trying, well this and well that"
"Okay--what haven't you done"
"We still do this and that"
"Well cut this and that"
"Well it takes time"
"Well it's been months"
"Well I'm trying and you guys don't understand"

No--we do understand.

One thing you can do immediately--even if you have to lose whatever pre-payments/deposits you might have made...is to enroll your daughter in public school (if she's not already). The school year hasn't started yet and it is the perfect time to fix that part of your budget.
 
peacefulgirl said:
Who are you talking about here? I certainly DO NOT live like a millionaire. Where do you get this stuff? I wouldn't even want to be a millionaire !!!!! ALL the crap that comes with that is NOT for us. Sorry... wrong agian!

Envious ??? The ones I am envious of would be the SAH parents that are SACRAFICING so much to do what is most important in this world !!! The Joneses are NOT anything I ever want to be. A new car means NOTHING to me. Having my nails done, NEVER have in my life!!! Drycleaning- NEVER. Lawn service -NEVER! Cable pay for shows channels -NEVER.

I am simple and you got me all wrong!

THe Jonses green grass and flowers and nice cars and what the heck ever .... I just look and think.... hmmm not where I put MY money. :) How different we all are....

million dollar home does not mean millionaire--first thing.

And I do not have you all wrong at all.

The introduction of the Joneses was in response to your Disney trip desires.

You've presented yourself a certain way. Your situation is not reconciling with the facts presented.

Millionaire was for the book Millionaire Next Door--and if you actually read the book--it isn't about your average millionaire, nor is it really about how you can become a millionaire per se.
 
CarolA said:
I have decided, you are just doing this to bait folks. However, while this sounds really cruel... you are becoming entertaining. I find myself coming back just to read the rebuttals. (Plus some posters have posted some great ideas on things that we tend to forget add up to REAL money!!!)

::yes::
 
Peacefulgirl, I think a lot has been read into your first post (and last year's thread), and many people are confused. Your later posts indicate that the shortfall you mentioned is just for this month, not an on-going thing, right? When you sat down with the numbers, were you looking at minimum payments, or just your usual payment amounts? If you can get back on track with higher payments later and just pay the minimums this month, will that help any? Did you or your DH get any overtime this month that you hadn't budgeted for? Without mentioning any numbers, are there any amounts that have changed since you first sat down with your budget?
 
Lisa loves Pooh said:
Can't tell the sarcasm---but everyone here--even those who you disagree with are only trying to help you.


Puhleeze! Sincere efforts to help are not what I get out of all posts, not at all. I don't know how many times OP can repeat her point -- she is trying to get ideas of what she might cut which she hasn't. She doesn't have to agree to do anything suggested, and it certainly appears to me that a few posters are just being argumentative, rude and sarcastic. And I agree that some people seem to get some perverse thrill from being mean and nasty in their posts. Do us all a favor. IF YOU DON'T BELIEVE OP, OR CANNOT HANDLE IF SHE DOES NOT CHOOSE TO DO EXACTLY WHAT YOU WANT THEN DON'T READ OR RESPOND TO THIS THREAD. Getting off topic via implications of "you're lying" or "I am so much better than you" has gotten old and I only managed to read about half of the posts thus far.

Some of us are also interested in things to cut corners which we may not know about or have forgotten -- automatic debits with additional charges or more frequently than required, increasing insurance deductibles, dropping no longer needed PMI insurance, and so forth. Instead of those type of responses, as requested by OP, there is some bizarre "gotcha" posts which are rude, critical and seemingly obsessed with insulting OP (my favorite must have been the slam about not tithing -- I am sure God was proud of that post!)

Why is it so hard to just respond to the issue, taking OP at face value, or IGNORING the thread?

Peaceful Girl, I don't have any pearls of wisdom at the moment. If I think of something I will post. Good luck and stay determined. :Pinkbounc
 
FredS said:
Puhleeze! *snip*

No one has said they are better than the OP on this thread.

I'm just as interested in the thread as anybody else and have provided helpful tips as well.

Short of a recipe for how to grow money on trees--we are just as interested in seeking the truth (without details) as we are in providing helpful advice so that the advice is appropriate for the situation.

Can't provide help if you don't know what is going on.

It sounds like OP is taking the paupers approach to get by when it just may not be necessary.
 
Well, I am glad this thread was started. I have been reading this thread on and off all day and have gained some good ideas from it and have been recommitted in my attitude about a lot of stuff I already knew but had gotten away from.

We don't have a lot of debt, but we also don't have savings and it seems like each month we are barely making it. Now, we used to have savings, but DH was unemployed for a long time and then had a lousy pay rate for another year. He is now making better money and we are almost caught up but these tips on here and the links for other sites are a great help.

So, thanks everyone.
 
PeaceGirl,

First of all, good for you to have never missed a payment or to even have made a late payment! That told me a lot about how bad (or not) your situation is and more importantly that you are responsible in making your monthly payments.

I just read this thread from the beginning and remember you saying earlier how you never missed or paid late and figured out (assumed) that even through you posted about being $400 short per month not accounting for food and gas, you were still coming up with the funds somehow (at least in the past) to pay the monthly bills that come up. It probably is an internal ponzi (sp?) thing, as someone suggested and you agreed with.

Based on my assumptions, I doubt you are in imminent danger of bankruptcy. Others based this on their assumption that you truly were short $400 each and every month and couldn't put food on the table because the shortage didn't cover food.

Now you may correct me if I'm wrong but reading between the lines, you did live beyond your means up to and including your 2 trips to WDW last year but managed to just barely keep your financial head above water by juggling around money, bills, and maybe some sort of unsecure loans/advances and also maybe using some previous money savings ideas from the disboards.

In a sense the previous budget savings tips helped you "afford" to make those WDW trips but NOT to cut your debt situation. So, while you certainly saved some money, it didn't help your bottom line much.

Your strategy worked so far even this past year and even with the 2 trips, but somehow it's been getting harder to do the "juggle" maybe because a loan source has dried up.

Now you are posting for additional help because you DON'T want to be late or miss any payments which you may be in danger of.

Hopefully you really want to get out of debt this time versus getting enough financial breathing room to justify another future trip.

Please don't feel defensive with posters getting frustrated. Maybe they made assumptions based on your posts that may not be 100% correct.

In response to their numerous references to your 2 WDW trips last year, you had hoped to put it behind you and start from scratch. It's done, money spent, nik-picking about it will not help your current situation.

True but many (including me) had maybe secretly wanted to hear from you that yes you had a great time and will always treasure the memories but in hindsight maybe it wasn't the smartest thing to do, maybe I should have put the money towards paying down debt instead and then things wouldn't look so bad now.

Since it seems you haven't expressed any regret for those past trip, some may fear that even if you do get any advice that can help you, that you will again "use up the advantage" by taking another WDW trip and you will be back to square one with even less options on how to get out of the hole.

I posted this on another thread. Thought is might apply here too:

SleepyatDVC said:
Many people don't understand why some people feel so strong about being able to afford paying for a Disney vacation. Many people do it on credit and have no problems with it - I guess that works for them. But if someone is "worried" about money already and is worried about affording a trip to Disney, then it's hard for me to imagine how the additional expense and the weeks, months, and maybe even years of worry over the added financial burden won't overshadow a week's worth of memories and fun.

Yes, I agree that memories for the kids are priceless, but I also know that tensions and worries at home over money and finances can affect the kids without you realizing it and can last a lifetime.


I really wish you the best of luck. I don't think it's impossible. I think you can do it.

I understand that there are things that you are not ready to cut and you may not need to YET, like your child's private school. I understand that your job situation is actually good and it would be hard to top it which makes it necessary to have 2 cars. Selling the house and downsizing or rent, sounds a lot easier than it is. These are all LAST resorts which many assumed you were down to. I suspect that it is not.

At least you know that you can always cut these major expenses as a last resort if you are ever in danger of bankruptcy. As someone who never misses a payment, I doubt that you will declare bankruptcy unless something major happens like job loss or illness.

Other then these major changes, what can you change? You kind of left us with only those things unless you can think of things you left out.

Do either of you have life insurance? My parents had cash value in theirs which they borrowed from at one point - it's all paid back now. But be careful if you do because when the market is low, your policy may be in dangering of lapsing if you don't pay the loan off.

DH has term life (very cheap now). I have a large UL policy that my parents bought me when I was a lot younger. We took over the payments when we got married but the premiums are really high. I was thinking of applying for a term life policy for the same amount or double of my existing policy. Once I get approved I would cancel my existing UL and keep the cash value (in the high 5 digits) in a separate account (maybe laddered CD's) just to pay for the new premiums.

Then I wouldn't have to pay any new money in but still have basically the same (or more) coverage. This will save me over $5k a year which is one of our largest expenses. I will try to get the 30 year term which will end when I am 66.

Hard decision but those premiums are killers and I assume the UL will run out if the insurance costs use up all the investment cash value? Maybe I show add $$ to the separate insurance account annually so that when the 30 year term expires and I'm still kicking, there are still $$ in the bank.

Something for me to think about.

PG, while we are trying to save you money, if you don't have life insurance, maybe you should think about some term insurance. You certainly don't want your kids to inherit and have to deal with your debts.

Anyway, more for you to think about too. Good luck again and please post when you have had time to think about everything.
 
First let me say don't get discouraged. I only read the first few posts so forgive me if I am saying something that has already been said.

I know someone mentioned Dave Ramsey (his book The Total Money Makeover has a lot of good advice). However, his program is a little tough and he advocates working on a budget and following his 7 baby steps. Most people can't budget and usually fail. It is like a diet. Most people can't stay on a strict diet for too long before they start to binge. They have to make it a way of life. Yes Dave's way can be done, but I fear that if you can't staye "Gazelle Intense" like he suggests that all your other financial goals fall to the way side. There is a better way:

Buy the Book "The Automatic Millionaire" by David Bach. He basically teaches the same things as Dave Ramsey, but David Bach has a better system that once it is set up - there is no room for failure. Both these books are great and give correct advice, but I think most people will have better success with David Bach's book.

Don't give up - get encourgement from these books and keep on going and you will see every year getting better.

I was once in Debt and managed to get out of it and build up a nice retirement fund and I'm 5 years away from paying off my mortgage. If I could do it anyone could do it.

If you want to visit David Bach's site it is called "FinishRich.com"
 
stemikger said:
First let me say don't get discouraged. I only read the first few posts so forgive me if I am saying something that has already been said.

I know someone mentioned Dave Ramsey (his book The Total Money Makeover has a lot of good advice). However, his program is a little tough and he advocates working on a budget and following his 7 baby steps. Most people can't budget and usually fail. It is like a diet. Most people can't stay on a strict diet for too long before they start to binge. They have to make it a way of life. Yes Dave's way can be done, but I fear that if you can't staye "Gazelle Intense" like he suggests that all your other financial goals fall to the way side. There is a better way:

Buy the Book "The Automatic Millionaire" by David Bach. He basically teaches the same things as Dave Ramsey, but David Bach has a better system that once it is set up - there is no room for failure. Both these books are great and give correct advice, but I think most people will have better success with David Bach's book.

Don't give up - get encourgement from these books and keep on going and you will see every year getting better.

I was once in Debt and managed to get out of it and build up a nice retirement fund and I'm 5 years away from paying off my mortgage. If I could do it anyone could do it.

If you want to visit David Bach's site it is called "FinishRich.com"

I love the David Bach books as well. They're full of really useful information.

I was just reading SleepyatDVC's post (nice post BTW), and while I agree that the OP probably isn't in imminent danger of Bankruptcy, one little mishap...one little slip-up....like an injury or job loss and well, game over. The OP mentioned in the September thread that she and DH both work in the telecom industry where job security isn't exactly a sure bet these days.

I guess what has happened with this thread that some of us simply got frustrated with the OP. There was an entirely different thread going on and the OP started her own(her right to do so) to draw attention to her financial issues. The plea was incredibly exuberant and appeared to truly be seeking some good and honest feedback. While she did ask for everyone to "be gentle", what she didn't say was that she was only looking for responses like..."Hey PG, don't get down, you can do it!!" and little else. As the thread went on some remembered an almost identical plea for help last September. The posts are nearly verbatim if you read them.

That thread contained 10 full pages of responses and advice which the OP gleefully accepted. I'm sure she made some changes, saw a little light in the monthly budget and decided to use the extra dough to make two trips to Disney World for a total of 14 days. Hey, it's a free country, do what you want with your money...no problem.

But then, she comes back in...with a nearly identical plea for help and fails to mention the previous post in September or the trips to WDW, or the fact that she had indeed been talking about and searching for AP rates for a trip this November just a few days ago. Now of course she says that there are no plans for a November trip. Personally, that's when I shook my head. Was I judging her, yes I probably was, because it sure as heck seemed to me that it was deja vu all over again. It seemed to me that she was saying that she needed help in order to get her finances in order when in fact she was looking for advice in order to find the funds for a trip to WDW that she can't afford.

Hey, I get that it's depressing to be in debt. I also understand that sometimes when you're in a hole and you can't see your way out that you figure, "hey...what the heck, I really want to go to Disney World, and damn the finances....I'm going." I understand that. I guess I wish that she had come in saying that to begin with.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom