We've only been on the one
dcl cruise, with another booked for next year. We really enjoyed most of the menus we had (animators was the least fav) but I loved the starters and mains from enchanted garden.
We sail on the fantasy next year and am hoping they don't change the menus too much, as we would love to have some of the items we loved from the last cruise (duck, steak, brie... I'm looking at you).
What I was told by someone, is that if you like something from a different restaurants menu for that night your server can get it for you. Is this true. I could eat the brie starter every night if allowed.
I also didn't mind the pirates menu. We were lucky to have the buffet on our last cruise too (just before they re stopped it) and we loved the Mexican food and pancakes. But get that it was too much waste.
I can understand why for those who have done plenty of dcl cruises you may be bored with the menus. But it's always a concern when they change menus, as sometimes the changes can be for the worse.