Pirates or Arabian Nights dinner show?

[sfoshee]

I need to make reservations for either the Pirates Adventure or Arabian Nights dinner shows for this upcoming weekend. Is one better than the other? Which would you recommend for a 4 year old little girl who loved Medieval Times? Thanks for your help!

 

[imgoingtodisney]

My MIL wants to go to Arabian Nights for her birthday. So on Oct 9th we will be at Arabian Nights. I hear this is good for girls. My son enjoyed Medieval Times 5 years ago when he was 4.