We have been on the one at the Grand Floridian twice, and my boys did enjoy it both times. The first time they got the bandanas with the Mickey ears, this was about 3 years ago, last October they only got a red bandana, and were a little disappointed, they really loved the ones with the ears. It also looked as if the gift bags had shrunk in size that they received. I always order some pirate stuff from Oriental Trading and make my own bags to give them when they get off the boat. Even the ride that day had changed, they used to stop at a shoe tree which had shoes hanging off of it and, but they didn't stop there that time. Had my older 2 not been on an earlier one, they wouldn't have known the difference. Overall, even with the changes, they still had a good time and would still recommend this activity for children.