Sorry I have been working on my trip report and I did mean to post this review here...
My twin sons (6) went on October 27th and the verdict was that they absolutely LOVED it!
This was well worth the $60 I paid, they had so much fun! They were given bandana's with their names on them to look like pirates then they shoved off on a boat with the crew. The boat looked like a shuttle boat not a pirate ship, that had rope netting draped along the sides and a Pirate Flag on the (darn I have no boat experience to speak off, so I will just call it the back of the boat). They went to three different places on an excursion, from what I gathered, one of the CM's tries to steal the map or treasure so they leave her/him on one of the islands. They go exploring and they just have a lot of fun doing it. They are given a bag lunch of peanut butter and jelly, I don't believe they have any alternatives whatsoever, and they do get a bag of booty when they exit the boat, small trinkets like a compass, and a telescope, rings, etc.. This is the treasure they find on one of the islands. If you can book it, do so! My kids really did have a great time.
If you have any other questions, please let me know.