Pilgrims and Indians; You've Got to be Kidding!!

DawnCt1

<font color=red>I had to wonder what "holiday" he
Joined
May 17, 2004
Messages
30,053
This tradition is as old as school. I remember dressing up in construction paper costumes as pilgrims and indians in K and 1st grade. Now it is so un PC that the police had to show up. Its KINDERGARTEN for goodness sake!

Police called over Thanksgiving dispute at Claremont school
Tensions rise as foes and backers of a longtime celebration involving kindergartners in Indian and pilgrim costumes demonstrate outside Condit Elementary. The district eliminated the costumes this yea
By Seema Mehta

November 26, 2008

Protesters descended Tuesday on Condit Elementary School in Claremont, tersely arguing over the construction-paper pilgrim and Native American costumes worn by kindergartners at a decades-old Thanksgiving tradition. Police were called to the school when tensions rose.

Officers also were monitoring Claremont Unified Supt. David Cash's home after he received hate mail and told police that he feared for his safety.

"It's been wild," said one woman who worked at the school. She declined to give her name because she wasn't authorized to speak on behalf of the school.

Cash and Condit Principal Tim Northrop did not return phone calls or e-mails seeking comment.

For four decades, children at Condit and Mountain View elementary schools have taken annual turns dressing up and visiting each other to share a Thanksgiving feast. Controversy erupted after district officials last week decided to eliminate the Native American and pilgrim costumes from this year's event after some parents complained that they were demeaning and stereotypical. Other parents were infuriated by the district's modifications of the event, saying that administrators had bowed to political correctness.

On Tuesday morning, some parents dressed their children in the hand-made headdresses, bonnets and fringed vests, and school officials did not force the students to remove them. Still, some parents vowed to keep their children home from school Wednesday, potentially costing the district state attendance funds.

Nearly two dozen protesters stationed themselves in front of the school, evenly split between costume supporters and opponents. The supporters set up a table with refreshments in front of the school sign, and several wore construction-paper headdresses. Foes stood about 40 feet away, carrying signs that said, "Don't Celebrate Genocide."

The discussion between the two groups grew so heated that school officials called police, and officials separated the protesters onto separate sidewalks, said Claremont Police Lt. Dennis Smith.

Meanwhile, the kindergartners frolicked nearby on the playground, Smith said.

"The kids were oblivious," he said, "as they should be."

Mehta is a Times staff writer.

seema.mehta@latimes.com

Times staff writer Lorraine Wang contributed to this story.

http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-claremont26-2008nov26,0,5638652,print.story
 
Sadly, I'm not surprised. It's ridiculous how PC Police creep into monitoring Pilgrim and Indian Thanksgiving costumes in a Kindergarten classroom. :sad2:

ETA: I guess my avatar could be un-PC. :confused3
 

What a sad commentary on how ridiculous things have gotten in this country.
 
Ridiculous;those parents should be ashamed of themselves- I mean it's history; the Indians were there as were the Pilgrims-what's the argument about?:confused3
 
/
OMG it's kindergarten!! :rotfl2: Maybe it would have been better if they did a play on how things actually went down? That would make for one memorable school play. ;)
 
Wow

I'm glad they didn't walk into my kindergarten class during our Thanksgiving feast yesterday. I had a room full of Indians. None of them would touch the Pilgrims outfits they made. When asked why the girls said they wanted to wear the jewelry and feathers. The boys said the Indians had nicer hats.

:lmao: :rotfl2: :lmao: :rotfl2:
 
And the moral of this story....

There really are times when adults act worse than the kindergartners...
Talk about needing a serious time out.
 
Who ARE these protesters? I mean, really. I work with a ton of people with little children. Plus, I've got a bunch of little kids in my immediate & extended family. NO one that I know would be offended in the least if their kids dressed up like a Pilgrim or an Indian for Thanksgiving! And one of my good friends is a full-blood American Indian. I mentioned this story to her and she just rolled her eyes and said "oh brother, people need to get a life".

So, who the heck ARE the people who get so offended so easily?
 
Nearly two dozen protesters stationed themselves in front of the school, evenly split between costume supporters and opponents. The supporters set up a table with refreshments in front of the school sign, and several wore construction-paper headdresses. Foes stood about 40 feet away, carrying signs that said, "Don't Celebrate Genocide."

Well, *if* the kindergarteners were actually reenacting the bad things that happened to native americans, they would have a point. But history has shown that many times, Indians and settlers got along quite well.

Idiots. Go save a whale.
 
NOTE THE PICTURE IN MY SIG...

If you are so politically correct that a kindergarten tradition held at probably the vast majority of schools in this country offends you.....you have some issues.

When my kids went to public school there was the same tradition. They dressed up and had a thanksgiving "feast" of their own. I remember doing it myself when I was in school. Is there any of us who DIDN'T do this in school? PC aside, what is wrong with teaching them the history of the holiday where TWO GROUPS OF OPPOSING PEOPLE CAME TOGETHER FOR THE GREATER GOOD AND LEARNED TO SHARE????

Seems as if those protestors could have learned a thing or two from the very thing they were protesting. I don't recall genocide ever being a part of the Thanksgiving history or tradition....
 
A lot of people really need to get lives. It's disturbing that they actually have time for such foolishness.
 
Oj for goodness sake! I did hear yesterday on the radio (don't remember which show) that some are wanting to rename ThanksGIVING- ThanksTAKING! whatever is this world coming to!
 
Good grief. It's not like they were celebrating the Trail of Tears or any number of later massacres (by both sides). Thanksgiving. It was happy. They got along at the time. That IS something to celebrate.

It's history. Get over it PC police. You can't eliminate the truth from history no matter how hard you try.
 
I bet nobody will be protesting on their paid holiday tommorow!:confused3

People really need to get a grip.
 
Worse than doing away with the costumes, IMO, is that some so-called "adults" can't question and disagree respectfully. Hate mail and getting so out of hand, in view of the children, that the police have to be called? :confused3 What a bunch of loons. On both sides.
 

PixFuture Display Ad Tag












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top