Monday, October 19th - Dinner at Il Mulino ... an Eye-Talian Delight Rather than a Mealtime Fright!
Jason and I go back and forth about trying Italian restaurants while we're at WDW for the same reason that we go back and forth about trying places like Yachtsman or Shulas: they are a dime a dozen in Stinktown. But recently we've started hearing good things about Il Mulino, located in the Swan, from people whose opinion we have relied upon in the past. These fine people had yet to steer us wrong so we decided to make a reservation and hope for the best. Guest X&Y opted not to join us, which ended up being good because Il Mulino was so busy that I'm not sure we could have snagged a table for four instead of two. Jay and I were surprised to see just how busy the restaurant was when we arrived for our 7:30 reservation; there must have been another convention gearing up for the week because it was packed and bustling and loud.
The restaurant is located on the Swan's main floor, just across the lobby from Kimonos. The walls are brick with colored glass block insets, the floors are hardwood, and the decor is sleek, comfortable contemporary. We really liked it - very clean lines and no visual clutter. We were seated at a small table for two near a large party of twelve and were initially concerned that we might be overlooked by our serving team because large parties, especially large parties of drunk business people, tend to be demanding but we were pleasantly surprised as the evening wore on and never felt that we received anything other than exemplary service.
To start we ordered a large bottle of Pellegrino, a glass of red wine for Jason, and an Italian Margarita for me. My DIS-buddy Robert P has long waxed eloquent about this drink and based on his recommendation and the menu description I decided to give it a try.
Margarita Italiana
This was so refreshing and not nearly as sweet as I feared it might be. Made with Don Julio Anjeo Tequila, Cointreau, Amaretto, Fresh Sour, and a splash of fresh Lime Juice, the sweet and sour in this drink were perfectly balanced. I could have easily downed two or three more but decided to stay on my good behavior and just nursed this one through the meal.
The restaurant provided a basket of fresh bread, some kind of herb-y breadstick, and a plate of salami, olives, peppers, oil, and other unidentifiable goop that I opted not to try but which Jay said was really tasty. I did like the salami but wasn't interested in the gloop - the bread selections were very good and I liked them plain as well as dipped in olive oil.
Fresh bread
Complimentary plate of slop and salami
We ordered two appetizers because we were really hungry and couldn't make up our minds - Parmigiano Reggiano for Two and Beef Carpaccio.
Chunks of aged cheese
I was a little disappointed in the presentation of the parmigiano - I have no idea why that lettuce leaf was on the plate unless someone thought it would distract us from the lack of balsamic. We wanted more cheese and less lettuce! However, the cheese was very, very good and once our server brought us the bottle of balsamic that we requested it was even better. Nothing makes the gutworm happy like chunks of aged, tasty cheese ... unless it's a wedge of soft, buttery cheese with a loaf of bread!
Our second appetizer was something that Jay and I have wanted to try for some time but the opportunity just hadn't presented itself until now: beef carpaccio.
Beefy goodness
Il Mulino's Beef Carpaccio is listed on their menu as thinly sliced Tuscan-style beef served with Arugula, Extra-Virgin Olive Oil, Fresh Lemon Juice, and Original Carpaccio Sauce created in the restuarant's top secret test kitchens.

We thought this was fabulous - the beef was flavorful and tender and the sauce provided a nice creamy kick (we think there may have been some horseradish in it). Thanks to the tastiness of this appetizer, Jay and I are now officially hooked on beef carpaccio and have been on the prowl for Stinktown restaurants that offer it - currently we've found one.
Yes; one.
But let's not dwell on the many shortcomings of Stinktown eateries ... allow me instead to tell you about our entrees. One of the things I liked about Il Mulino is that even at dinner they allow patrons to order half-or-full-size portions. I selected a half-order of Penne Rigate, which was penne noodles served with Il Mulino original marinara sauce and ricotta cheese.
Penne Rigate
I loved this selection! While a very simple dish, what made it for me was the light application of marinara sauce. Stinktown Eye-talian eateries tend to drown their pasta in sauce which really upsets my intestinal goblin - this was just right in my book and allowed for a nice mix of flavors between the sauce and the cheese without allowing either to overpower the other.
Jason selected one of the evening specials - lobster risotto. He was nice enough to allow me a taste and while I'm not typically a big lobster eater this was exceptionally tasty. The risotto was perfectly cooked and there were generous chunks of lobster and shrimp meat scattered amongst it; the cheese sauce was again applied very lightly and prevented the dish from becoming gacky as it cooled down.
Lobster Risotto
We knew we wanted to split a dessert but nothing was really jumping off the menu at us. Our server suggested the Tartufo, which she said was her favorite of all the restaurant's dessert options. Wondering what the heck it is? According to the menu it is Eye-talian gelato encased in chocolate and served with whipped cream and zabaglione.
Tartufo unspoiled
Tartufo busted open
Jay and I thought this was great - a light, creamy and chocolatey end to our evening that really satisfied both our sweet tooths without leaving us feeling stuffed or heavy. And imagine our happy surprise when our wonderful server showed up at the table with a bucket of chilled limoncello! These shots were on the house and since Jay and I have never been ones to bypass alcoholic bounty we both indicated that we'd like to try a glass. It was terrific - slightly sweet and tasting wonderfully of lemon without any of the sourness or citrus acidity that the fruit typically provides, we could have sat there for the remainder of the night and finshed that bucket off all by ourselves!
Limoncello service
Chilled Limoncello - yum!
And there you have it - a wonderful meal and experience that truly surprised us in all the right ways. Il Mulino provided a varied menu with tasty choices designed to satisfy both the plain eater as well as the more adventurous. Everything was well prepared and the service was great. One of the things Jay and I really appreciated, and which we don't see often, was that while all the servers were very busy they were also all helping each other out. We went through three large bottles of Pellegrino that night and each one was replaced by a different server who happened to notice that we needed more while our primary server was tied up with another table. That is the way service should be - attentive and helpful without being intrusive - and we really appreciated it and made sure to pass our thoughts along to management before we left. For these reasons we plan on paying Il Mulino another visit this fall and award them our highest rating: