Parents, why do you give your children a choice when it's really not a choice at all?

My son is 19, attends college, and lives at home. I do not give or refuse permission when he goes somewhere. I may ask if he has his phone with him and I always want to know when he is coming home, but that's it. And yet, he STILL asks, "is that ok?" when he tells me his plans! Old habits are hard to break - for "kids" and parents! :rotfl:
 
Tbut if they followed through with the choice, their parent(s) would not be very happy with them for a while.

Hey, like everybody says, parents 'worry'.
Parents can be too 'free' with their own personal opinons...

However, the part I copied above is a different story...
If there is heck-to-pay (not very happy with you for awhile) just because you have an honest difference of opinion or want to stretch your wings a little bit.... That part would be a whole different situation.

PS... you are only 19... do remember that growing up and going out on your own are not just something that 'is'... It is an ongoing process that might take a while for both you and your parents! ;)

Truly being grown up and independant is KNOWING that your parents have their opinions, but you are able to go right past that and not let that have undue effect... You the maturity and self confidence to go on and do what is right for YOU.

I am well over 40..... I have been married for 20 years.... And, I can say that my husband took a LOT longer than age 19 to begin to do this.
 
Your sweet Mom is worrying about her daughter, that's all;)

Wait...just wait until your a Mom. You start worrying when you find out your pregnant and it never stops!
 
Thank you for all of your replies. :goodvibes You're are right, this really isn't that big of a deal, I do understand where my mom is coming from, it is just that sometimes It's hard to hear when I really want to do something. As far as moving out, I think that would be blowing this way out of proportion. I don't hate living here; I just disagree with what my parents say sometimes, don't we all do this? I was just curious if other parents did the same thing with giving their children a choice, but if they followed through with the choice, their parent(s) would not be very happy with them for a while. I understand I live under their roof and it is their rules; I'm not going to move out just because I disagree here and there. I don't feel as though I need to prove I am an adult to anyone. I think It's a responsible decision right now to be living at home and saving my money so I don't have years and years of student loans to pay in the future. I found the posts about being a people-pleaser and shifting the guilt to be the most helpful, as I think I am a people pleaser and when my mom is extremely worried about me doing something she does shift the guilt. Thanks again for all of the replies!

Answering bolded....

Nope, I don't play games like that. When I express my worry, my dd reassures me and then all is well.

You have to train us.:lmao:
 

My parents told me that they'd worry about me until they "married me off." :rotfl: This was after it took me 2 hours to call them back (I was seeing a movie in the afternoon!) and told them that if I took a day to call back, then they can freak out. They're always going to worry about me. If I'm on the road for work, I call when I'm back in the hotel safe at night. Personally, I'd rather have parents that worry than ones that don't care.
 
coolshannie, she's your mother and she worries. I have a worry wart mother. I am almost 48 years old and if I call her on the phone, she asks me if my doors are locked. I make a joke of it and say "No, Mom, the doors are wide open and I put up a neon sign that says 'I'm alone, I'm naked and the doors are unlocked' so the rapists will know which house to come to". If it's the middle of July and 80 degrees with 90% humidity she will ask me why I don't have a little jacket with me in case it gets chilly. It's her personality...she has always been the anxious, over-thinking sort, and I am not going to change her now.

When I was your age and living home, I did exactly what a PP suggested...when there was going to be a late night, I slept at a friend's house whose mother was less of a worrier. Then my mother had no idea what time we were going out, staying out until or anything else. Would I have liked to have had a "girlfriend" relationship with my mother? Well, maybe...but my mother wasn't built that way...still isn't. There's a lot that goes on now that I don't tell my mother, just because she is such a worrier. Sometimes she gets mad if she finds out some other way and says "Why didn't you tell me?" and I respond honestly "Because you worry too much and it drives me insane". Last year I had a TIA (mini-stroke). I did a whole neurological and cardiac work-up & didn't tell my mother until I thought I might need to have cardiac surgery...at that point I figured I had to tell her because she'd notice if I went missing for a week or so while having the surgery! ;) As it turned out, I didn't need surgery but the 2 weeks between when I told her and when it was determined that I didn't need surgery were hellish...every day it was "How do you feel? Do you think you should go to work? Shouldn't you just rest at home? I'll come clean your house so you don't have to" (didn't take her up on that, stupid me! ;)) and so forth. When it snows she worries about me driving and thinks I should call out to work... I don't like to lie to her, so I tell myself that not telling someone something is not lieing...if she directly asks me something I will answer her truthfully. But I pay for it in the aggravation of then constantly having to reassure her.

The unfortunate part is that your mother doesn't realize that by being how she is, she is actually going to push you away a bit, there will be parts of you and your life that she just won't know about.
 
You were given a choice. It is up to you to "go". There is no such thing as "non choice". There is "yes" and there is "no".

In the movie situation your parents are worried about you doing new things. It is up to you to reassure them that you are going to be fine.

Exactly.

You had a good opportunity there, and you let the way you have been reacting to your parents cover it up! That was an opportunity to get online, go to a map site, find the place, get a good solid and safe route to and from. Or you could have figured out your most trustworthy friend to take you there and back. Worked out a deal where you will start searching the city more and more, so that you are familiar with it (as you would have been doing had you gone away to college).

This would have helped you do what you want to do AND would have grown the trust and the faith in your abilities in all of you.

I was just curious if other parents did the same thing with giving their children a choice, but if they followed through with the choice, their parent(s) would not be very happy with them for a while.

Something it's better to learn sooner rather than later? If the only "punishment" is that they aren't happy with you, that's not a punishment! That's simply the feelings of people who love you, and you are going to *have to* figure out that someone being unhappy for a little while isn't the end of the earth. Learn that now and learn to deal with the feelings inside, so you don't have to learn it 10 years from now when married with a baby, having to tell ONE of the sets of parents that you will be spending the holidays with the OTHER set of parents! :goodvibes
 
OP-today you should have made a test run in daylight-scouted out the area, found parking etc
Could a sorority sisiter drive with you then come spend night-safety in numbers and all that:)
 
what about staying at a hotel for the night so you don't have to drive home until the morning. If your budget permits it may be safer than driving home with all the drunks on the road. Maybe you could invite a friend or two to stay with you and make a fun night of it and go out for breakfast the next morning.

Us moms do worry, some more than others. My son will be 23 next month and he is in graduate school in Japan, going on his second year there...I worry all the time and he doesn't even drive there. sounds like your Mom loves you so much she just worries:grouphug:
 
You were given a choice. It is up to you to "go". There is no such thing as "non choice". There is "yes" and there is "no".

In the movie situation your parents are worried about you doing new things. It is up to you to reassure them that you are going to be fine. I should know my dd is almost 19 as well.;)

Now if you are saying that your parents are "sabotaging" you because of their worry, then that is maturity on your part (aka the non choice). At some point with your parents, you will weigh what they say and then give them a hug and tell them you are going to be fine.

That is how you grow up.:goodvibes

OP, your mom gave her opinion, she didn't forbid you to go - she's a mom, she'll worry, it's part of the job description. However, *if* she is all the time weighing in with some negativity on every. single. thing. you try to do then that is different.

If you dislike living at home so much and feel like you're getting smothered, then maybe you should get an apartment. Perhaps you could share a place with a sorority sister or two?

agnes!

IMO, your mom was just giving her opinion. It's up to you to make the decision. At 2:30 a.m., you'll likely be tired, it will be very dark and more difficult to navigate your way home. There will be more people out and about who may be drunk or are up to no good as you're walking to your car. As other posters said, she's your mom, so she worries. She's given you her opinion, but it's up to you to make the decision. When will she stop doing this? Never. She'll still be giving you her opinion as long as she lives. ;)

Parents are always going to give opinions - I'm almost 50 and I still get opinions from my mom. But your the one making the choice. Part of growing up is understanding the difference between hearing an opinion from a parent and being told what to do by a parent. If you're still being told what to do by your parents - and by that I mean in your everyday decisions, not the "don't come in late as it disrupts the household" type decisions - then you might want to consider getting your own place or swapping to an out of state school.

I agree with all of the above - as well as others who have basically said the same thing.. Your parents were giving you "opinions" - and then the "choice" was left to you..:)

I don't see where there was any "non-choice"..:confused3
 
what about staying at a hotel for the night so you don't have to drive home until the morning.

OP-today you should have made a test run in daylight-scouted out the area, found parking etc
Could a sorority sisiter drive with you then come spend night-safety in numbers and all that:)

It seems the OP was posting last night, after this was all said and done. I bet it was for Alice, as it was a midnight movie premiere...

For the future she needs to get to know the city better, and start helping her parents see her as the adult she is, and not worrying so much about what they think about her mature decisions, but it's too late for this movie.
 
Thanks again for the replies. :goodvibes It was for Alice. It's all good and dandy though, a few others of my sorority sisters weren't able to make it either and we are all going to see it tomorrow instead. :goodvibes
 

New Posts





Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom