To have two employees not understand the rule shows a slippage in basic training. The OP purchased via internet. The rule has been forever that a PAP or AP purchased by phone (or on-line) does not begin to run until you pick it up at guest services. Moreover, all Disney tickets of any kind have never started when you purchase them by phone but instead start after you get or first use them at WDW. In other words, the rule the two employees tried to create is one they could not possibly have been taught and they just made it up.
Yes, they both made errors. Good help is hard to find, lol! You are right about how the passes work.
Too bad they couldn't just clone Cheshire Figment! Or make them ALL read his sticky! But my guess is most ticketing cm's are not retired cpa's - if they were it would be good for the customer and good for Disney!
But the lesson learned is if you don't succeed, try again. You'll eventually get a different answer.
I don't want this statement to be confused with 'trying to get something over' on Disney.
But, I imagine like many companies, Disney employees at ticket booths have to deal with people who expect extra or something for nothing. So, instead of looking at the 'mistake' the employees made, they may have jumped to the conclusion that jcf was trying to scam them and 'just said no' without even checking.
Case in point: I called Disney Ticketing to buy 2 PAP's with gift cards. I obtained my discounted gift cards legally and they should be good on any Disney merchandise, no matter how I choose to purchase it. The cards do not state that you can't use multiples by phone. MS just says they are 'unable to process' because of their system. So MS sends me to Ticketing, who is able to process such a transaction.
The first Ticketing CM says no way no how, even after I explained to her what I was told and that MS sent me to them. I return to MS with my story and I am told to try again. I also recheck the threads I've read on these boards. And I'm still reluctant to call. Because the first Ticketing agent made me feel as if I was trying to get some special favor done that was not allowed.
Later on another day, I call back. This time I receive the 'no problem' and all the pixie dust in Disney. I then felt good about my purchase.
So, I feel bad for jcf. I feel as if he had to claim what he bought and prove that he was owed it. And then the CM made him feel as if they were making an exception for him. Not good. Crowded room - everybody else listening to your business!
Maybe jcf should recount his experience in writing to Disney (not MS) so his experience could be used in training. Even Disney wants to retain happy customers. This will happen again to others....there's a whole year of PAP's to go.