I want to counsel caution in your concerns. We too were
very worried about how bad it was going to be at Chef Mickey's. Before we left for Disney World, having read so many negative concerns on here, we almost switched our reservations. I'm very glad we didn't. Bear in mind that people's perceptions from the Monorail platform,
or even from the check in desk are not always the same as the conditions inside the restaurant. Also, everyone's tolerance for inconvenience is different.
We were there a few weeks ago. We ate at Chef Mickey's both for lunch and dinner. During lunch time, the noise walking up to the podium was really loud. We were virtually shouting over the CM as we were checking in. I thought it was going to be miserable inside Chef Mickey's and figured we might have to leave.
But it wasn't miserable. Not at all. Don't ask me to explain the dynamics of noise but once you move away from the check in desk and over to your table, at least where we sat, the noise was minimal. I would expect the noise over in the section of the dining room by the dessert bar to be louder. We were seated directly across from the center of the buffet.
We did not see any dust and there was no work going on near the food areas.
At dinner time, there was no work going on at all.
I understand the work on the new quick service place should be done in October. But of course, nothing is certain. I would think if you had plans to be there in December or afterwards, you won't have any of these issues to contend with.
Again, everyone's experience might vary, but if you love eating at Chef Mickey's and you have an upcoming reservation, don't let a few experiences from other people scare you off. If you get to your table and you find the noise unbearable, you can ask to have your table moved to the other side of the restaurant. I'm about as picky as it gets when it comes to inconvenience and in our experience, eating there two times during our stay, once you got past the check in desk, the noise and smell were not an issue. And while your mileage my vary, when it comes to Disney World as with all things, no situation is perfect. You could be seated in a completely construction-noise free restaurant, like say 1900 Park Faire and get seated next to a large party of loud people and have a waitress who disappears for 30 minutes at a time.
Just my .02. I hope that helps some of you who have upcoming visits planned.