My DD (6) loves OKW. We have stayed at All Star Music before and she really didn't like it. We enjoy having extra space in the room, which All Stars definitely do NOT have. Remember they do not have refrigerators or microwaves in the rooms (honestly there isn't much room for a frig, even though you can rent one I think). I also don't know if the construction is different, but we could hear everything the people in the rooms around us at All Stars said and did. It wasn't much fun. The crowds at the pool were quite rowdy and the largest pool (the one with Donald and a fountain at All Star Music) had to be closed a number of times because of young children having "accidents" in the pool. Remember, if you want a slide, All Stars do not have pool slides. I don't think the pools at All Stars are anything special, although they do have some theming. The food court at the All Stars is pretty nice, with the refillable drink mugs. I guess it all depends on what you want. OKW does have more amenities and activities, i.e., sand volleyball, boat rides, etc. I thought the bus service wasn't the best at the All Stars. You had to share with all 3 of the All Star resorts. You would wait quite a while, having the bus you wanted go by, but it was too full to let anyone on. Having said all that, they are an economical alternative, especially if you want to save your points. Just remember you aren't going to have much space. If I didn't want to use points I would probably go off-site (I know, what a terrible thought) to Caribe Royal (see mousesavers.com for a special rate) and have much more space (we like a "home away from home" atmosphere), pool with water slide, etc. Good luck with your planning and whatever you decide I am sure it will be great!