Its all 100% down to personal choice.
April 2009 we booked for Sept 2011 - after lots of research on the internet and reading threads like this about the two resorts we booked OKW.
Fast forward to Sept 2009 - We were staying in Conorado Springs, had a meal booked at DTD and about 3 hours to kill before the reservation. We drove to OKW and had a look around. We thought it was really nice and we were really looking forward to our visit. It actually reminded us of Conorado Springs where we were staying only with a different theme.
We then went to Saratoga Springs - We immediately realised that we preferred the feel of the resort to OKW, it just felt newer and more plush and dare I say it more grand. In a way it reminded us of Animal Kingdom Lodge where we had stayed in 2008. We also had a look around and decided that we would look at changing our booking when we got home. However we were hoping to convince some friends to join us with 2 children and we didn't want to change the booking in case they decided to come and they would prefer OKW, so we waited.
As time went by it came to be that our friends did book, but they booked a Villa at SSR but in August because they didn't want to take the kids out of school. We couldn't face going during the busier times and we already had our flights and other stuff booked.
I phoned to pay off some of the holiday in early 2010 and I asked if we could change the resort to SSR from OKW. The woman wasn't massively helpful - the first time I have ever experienced that with disney - and wasn't sure it was possible and if it was we would have to pay a really big admin charge for swapping. We decided that we were just going to stick with what we had and maybe go to SSR another time.
We phoned to pay off the balance this weekend and I mentioned to the woman on the phone that we really wanted to stay at SSR but I guess its fully booked and there would be a huge admin charge to change. She was so helpful, a few minutes of general chit chat later and she had priced up the change of resort for us. To change to SSR from OKW for the same dates, same type of accomadation, same park tickets,
DDP etc was goign to cost us exactly £0.
Both are lovely resorts - we just preferred SSR when we looked around them both. SSR being close to DTD was also nice as I have never drunk in Disney as I am always driving so it will be nice to go out for a meal and not have to worry about the car or drinking for once
