Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[ShuisFan584]

The award for worst performance of the night goes to Scott, and obviously that's not a good thing. I will even go as far as to say that that performance was worse than any of Janay's. It was so incredibly bad and I'm surprised that the judges didn't bite his head off for it!

Even though Nikko was pretty bad too, I think Scott was much worse, and he pretty much showed that he wants to go home now.

As for Anwar, wow he was pretty bad too. In the beginning I had him picked to be in the top 4, but he has been getting worse and worse these past few weeks. I wouldn't be surprised if he goes sometime in the next 2-3 weeks.

The opposite is true for Vonzell. I thought she would have been one of the first few to leave the competition, but she has been doing better and better and picking up more fans, so she could easily be in the top 5.

I was watching last night with my parents and 2 of my friends, and we were all very surprised at some of the judges comments, because they were so opposite of ours. When Nikko performerd, we all agreed that he was blah, boring and bad, yet Simon told him it was refreshing! And then when Anthony performed and we all thought he did really well, and heard nothing out of tune, Simon told him he was excrutiating!

The bottom 3 tonight should definitely without a doubt be Nikko, Scott and Anwar, with Nikko or Scott going home. Whichever one doesn't go home tonight, has to be the one to go next week.

Although I think the bottom 3 might actually be Anthony (although maybe his fans will keep him out since he was just in the bottom last week), Scott and possibly Jessica.

 

[dturner]

I love Constantine but his choice of songs confuses me. After hearing that it was 90's songs I thought oh yay there are a lot of GREAT rock songs from the 90's but no one did ANY OF THEM!!!!

Ok - who's going home tonight - I say Scott or Jessica - I just don't like Jessica at all, I think Carrie is much better.

 

[phisigprincess]

Still think Carrie's the best. I hope people finally wise up and send Scott packing. He still really creeps me out.

 

[IloveDMB]

Still think Carrie's the best. I hope people finally wise up and send Scott packing. He still really creeps me out.

I am totally with you on this. Scott creeps me out big time. Where are his eyes? And how many weeks can he wear glasses? Come on now, time for him to go home.

 

[ckay87]

I've given up on most of the guys. I was absolutely crazy about Anwar from the very first audition. But he's just going downhill and it makes no sense. I love his voice but it's like he's becomming increasingly unable to use it.

 

[grinningghost]

My guesses for who's leaving are Scott, Anthony and Jessica. All of them put out dull performances last night.

I disagree about Anwar. I still think he's great and thought he did a wonderful job last night. Nikko was good too.

By far the best performance last night was Vonzell.

Constantine surprised me. I thought he sang that mellow old song really well. He showed that his voice is actually GOOD, and he doesn't need to scream lyrics to attract attention.

Carrie is a good singer and very pretty, but I hate to say it, she kind of bores me.

 

[dturner]

Constantine surprised me. I thought he sang that mellow old song really well. He showed that his voice is actually GOOD, and he doesn't need to scream lyrics to attract attention.

I think that's why he is picking the songs he has - to show that he CAN SING and has a good voice. Although I was a bit surprised and confused as to his song choice last night - who originally sang that song??? I can't place it at all.

 

[snoopy]

No that was Shunta Worthington. They had a similiar look but Shunta was a bit more "manly" looking.. (hate to say that but it is true)

Wow, I didn't know this. I thought that it was Vonzell who missed the bus and I was sort of annoyed with her because of it! Thanks for clearing that up, Cindy!

 

[Dodie]

I think that's why he is picking the songs he has - to show that he CAN SING and has a good voice. Although I was a bit surprised and confused as to his song choice last night - who originally sang that song??? I can't place it at all.

Bonnie Raitt

 

[grinningghost]

What did everyone think about Nadia last night? I really thought she was good and I loved her outfit. The judges didn't seem too impressed though.

 

[dturner]

Bonnie Raitt

Well that explains why "this rocker" didn't know that song, LOL!!!!

Still think Constantine is GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[grinningghost]

Well that explains why "this rocker" didn't know that song, LOL!!!!

Still think Constantine is GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I think Constantine was probably doing this after Simon said he did better than Bo last night. What about you?

 

[CrazyChristie416]

Who do you think is going home tonight?

Crystal

 

[grinningghost]

Who do you think is going home tonight?

Crystal

Either Scott, Anthony or Jessica - I can't decide which one.

 

[MinnieM21]

Who do you think is going home tonight?

Crystal

Scott, he was just awful!

 

[orangeblossom]

Scott

 

[cats7494]

I think there is a good chance that Scott will be going home..he did not do well at all!
I usually like his voice - but it was pretty bad!

 

[MamaLema]

I want whatever Paula's on. Looks like fun!

Yup. I agree. It really bugged me last night though when she went out of her way to praise all those bad performances and and then told Vonzell she did OK, or something like that. That surprised me. Vonzell was one of the best last night and I'm not ever her fan

 

[grinningghost]

Yup. I agree. It really bugged me last night though when she went out of her way to praise all those bad performances and and then told Vonzell she did OK, or something like that. That surprised me. Vonzell was one of the best last night and I'm not ever her fan

Paula is clearly doing happy pills or something. I agree - Vonzell was the best last night. She looked really pretty with her hair curled too.

 

[dturner]

I think Constantine was probably doing this after Simon said he did better than Bo last night. What about you?

Yup, I agree and was a little surprised that Simon gave Constantine that compliment!!!

So, now I've been researching Constantine and I'm impressed with his credentials/resume, graduated from the Boston Conservatory, in the touring version of Rent, has his own rock band - this boy will go far!!!!

I know I'll be a fan of whatever Constantine does - I just love that name!!!