Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[aprilgail2]

My favs tonight in order are...
Vonzell-awesome!
Bo-always a fav to me!
Constantine-one of his better performances
Carrie
Nadia
Anwar
Jessica
Anthony-not his best
Nikko-I just can't stand his "singing"-I hope he goes instead of scott but I don't think that will happen.
Scott -really bad tonight!

 

[Philadisney]

my friend just sent me this link, he found anwar on an online dating site
http://love.blackplanet.com/Profile/view.html?profile_id=2855519

 

[Cindy B]

Bo- Nice stage presence but not a fan of tonight for him
-Jessica- Not bad tonight, although she could have sang Nadias song better
Anwar- Whats happening Anwar? Loved the new do (anyone else notice that? Wonder if its real hair...) But the song wasn't great. I am firmly on the Anwar train, but its just didn't do it for me.

-Nadia- She has an extremely limited range but makes good use of it. She performs to downplay the lack of range

Constantine- Not great either
-Nikko-He doesn't do a thing for me, I can fast forward through his performance

Anthony-ZZZZ Glad to see the glassses gone. I had read from a local "friend" that they were only a prop anyway. Was it just me or did the Russian accent come in strong in the first part of the song.
-Carrie- Boring little blond robot. See Carrie Sing. See Carrie sing country. See Carrie smile on cue. Boring!
-Scott- He will be going home. What is up with the southern accent? Shaker Heights Ohio is not the deep south.. I know I used to live there!
-Vonzell-WOW! She knocked it out!

 

[sweet angel]

my friend just sent me this link, he found anwar on an online dating site
http://love.blackplanet.com/Profile/view.html?profile_id=2855519

I'm almost afraid to ask....why was he looking?

 

[Cindy B]

Well that dating link was interesting to say the least. What is he looking for?

Hey... anyone interested? He sure is a cutie, but those pictures aren't good.

I'm 34, and 120 miles of Elizabeth NJ, and don't smoke.. wonder if he'll take me. I'm working on the bachelors degree.

 

[cheeringmom]

AAACK I missed it. I forgot to turn on the VCR before I left and I missed it ack!!!!!! Anywhere I can hear the songs they sang? or maybe they will do a rerun???????ackkkkkkkk

 

[ChrisnSteph]

Well that dating link was interesting to say the least. What is he looking for?

Hey... anyone interested? He sure is a cutie, but those pictures aren't good.

He is looking for a MAN. I'm sure he doesn't need a dating service now!

Correction: I think I read that webpage wrong. I don't know what gender he prefers!

 

[izzy]

I don't know if anyone has brought this up before, but is Nadia the girl who's singing about Bermuda shorts on the Old Navy commercial? It sure looks like her!

BTW, loved Carrie's performance tonight, but she was also singing one of my all-time favorite songs! Most everyone was so-so for me tonight except for Carrie and Vonzell. I like Vonzell more and more each week.

I wish someone in last week's dissection of AI hadn't said anything about Constantine being creepy because of the way his eyes always follow the camera. That's all I noticed when he sang tonight - LOL!

I'm just not a Scott fan. I know this is mean, but every time I see him I think about that Seinfeld episode where Kramer is looking for the pig man in the hospital, and I think that Scott could have played that part.

 

[Cindy B]

He is looking for a MAN. I'm sure he doesn't need a dating service now!

Where does it say that? I looked under about me and what I (Anwar) is looking for and it didnt say SBM seeking other Single Male or anything like that.

I just went to blackplanetlove and went under men seeking men and Anwar's profile did NOT COME UP! So it was not under man vs. man.

I know Anwar is a teacher, and his reputation can/needs to be protected. Parents have a way of becoming non supportive of alternative lifestyle when thier children are concerned. And before the flames come, I had a gay male teacher the entire 6th grade, and nothing became of me! However, other parents hated the fact that he was so effeminate.

 

[Tina]

There are 2 tabs. One says "I Am." The other says "I am Looking For...." He is looking for a man 5'7 to 6'2 who is athletic/muscular.

 

[Cindy B]

There are 2 tabs. One says "I Am." The other says "I am Looking For...." He is looking for a man 5'7 to 6'2 who is athletic/muscular.

So then why is this not under man seeking man? that is what I want to know. There are only 25 man seeking men in NJ and none were Anwar.

 

[ChrisnSteph]

Where does it say that? I looked under about me and what I (Anwar) is looking for and it didnt say SBM seeking other Single Male or anything like that.

When I clicked on the link, I assumed the "I Am" and the "I'm Looking For..." was Anwar's profile. Both stated Male as the gender, so that's why I thought he was looking for a man! I'm a dork.

 

[Philadisney]

-Carrie- Boring little blond robot. See Carrie Sing. See Carrie sing country. See Carrie smile on cue. Boring!

haha you rule! i totally agree

 

[Tina]

Dunno
...but in reading his page, is pretty clear. Sorry Cindy B.

 

[sweet angel]

There are 2 tabs. One says "I Am." The other says "I am Looking For...." He is looking for a man 5'7 to 6'2 who is athletic/muscular.

You're right. That's kind of a risky thing for a teacher to do, no? I'd imagine that could create a boatload of problems for him.

 

[Philadisney]

You're right. That's kind of a risky thing for a teacher to do, no? I'd imagine that could create a boatload of problems for him.

that was my first reaction too. i don't mean about stating the gender preference, i mean about having any sort of dating profile online....just imagine if one of your student's parents found you (or worse, your students)...aaaaaakward.

 

[Cindy B]

I find that extremely risky for a teacher to do that. I personally would never do anything like that because my students are extremely internet savvy, and anything would come back and bit me in the Butt!

If that is what he is, so be it. But it isn't officially listed as men seeking men, and believe it or not I looked at all 25 from NJ. I didn't want to look at the ones from NY, so I didnt.

 

[Tina]

I'm not so sure I would call it risky. I don't have a problem with it - but then again, I have several gay friends. Maybe its a Jersey thing.... I am friends with a gay couple who are contemplating adoption and are looking at different areas of the country where they would consider raising children. New Jersey is at the top of their list due to more liberal laws and minds. This is my friend's opinion - I really don't know much about it. But since he's been researching it, I would assume he knows what he's talking about. Me, I'm just a clueless breeder. LOL

 

[ChrisnSteph]

Dunno
...but in reading his page, is pretty clear. Sorry Cindy B.

So I didn't read it wrong? Good! I was starting to feel bad for potentially harming his reputation. (BTW, I wasn't slamming him for being gay, I was just posting what I thought I saw.)

 

[Cindy B]

Well just because legislative is liberal it doesnt necessarily mean that parents in the school district are... parents can ruin a teachers reputation quickly. I've seen it happen. Non tenured teachers get FIRED if a parent doesn't like them and complain... I've seen it!

BTW there are 208 men seeking men in NY for 25-29 and none were Anwar. I'd like to know where his profile is hiding on that site.