Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Octoberbeauty said:
You think Constantine is fat? :confused3 I can see him not being your "type", but fat? :confused3 I don't get it.


Go Carrie. You Rock!! :cheer2:

His face is a bit chubby but he's definately not fat!

Scott - time to go - sorry to those that like him!

Christine
 
8. Carrie-- Don't know this song either -- She sounds a little flat in some areas. Not bad, but not the best performance tonight. I've heard her do better.

9. Scott-- "One Last Cry"-- A little pitchy on a couple of notes, but he did pretty well with the high notes. Not what I would have chosen for him, but he "worked it out" okay.
 
Great job Carrie!!

Scott- Good singer, even though I can't stand that Brian Mcknight song.
 
Vonzell - Wow!! her best performance so far in this competition! imo
 

VonzelleS performance, one word.............INCREDIBLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Best performance of the night, IMO.
 
Vonzell........... WOW WOW WOW. I love her and have since day one. Awesome job!!!!
 
As soon as I heard the song intro, I thought she was done for. She gave me chills!
 
Wow - this is going to be tough. If I had to guess, I'd say Anthony or Nikko will be gone.
 
01-Bo- Just don't get the hype, never will. :confused3 I agree with Simon.
02-Jessica- Wow, I think she's sounds great tonight! Totally disagree with the judges, I liked her tonight because the song wasn't all "glory notes."
03-Anwar- I like him less and less each week and I want to like him. Tonight was just eh for me.
*Side note- Paula needs to go to rehab, asap.*
04-Nadia- Definite improvement over last week, pretty good tonight.
05-Constantine- It was OK. Didn't think it was as good as the judges though but I really hate that song so it clouds my judgement.
06-Nikko-His dad was a professional baseball player?! I really liked him tonight. LOL, my DD(8) said she wants to marry Nikko.
07-Anthony- I enjoyed his performance, liked his new look.
08-Carrie- I don't like this song. Lots of back up vocals again. It was OK, not bad but just eh. Totally disagree with Randy.
09-Scott- Oh geez I think this performance is pretty terrible.
Rehab Paula rehab, go now
10-Vonzell-Tough song, great job though, I think she pulled it off overall.

Best- Vonzell & Nikko
Going home- Scott?
 
10. Vonzell-- "If I Don't Have You"-- Probably one of the best performances of the night. Very strong vocally tonight, and great choice of song.




Nobody really stood out that much for me tonight, but right now I'm caught between Vonzell, Anthony, and Nikko. IMHO, they were the top 3 this week.
 
wow vonzell blew me away....she gave me chills. i'll be pushing for her tonight, i'll also vote for nadia and scott (didn't like his performance too much, but i enjoy him on the whole and really want to see him stay in the competition). i do agree that nadia needs to pick a melodic song, it's like okay, we KNOW you have a huge voice already...i might vote for bo if i can get through.

of course last week i couldn't get through for ANYONE all night, so it probably doesn't matter :rolleyes:
 
My choices from top to bottom:
Vonzell
Carrie
Bo
Constantine
Nikko
Nadia
Anthony
Jessica
Anwar
Scott
 
Vonzell has definitely come on strong the past couple weeks. Carrie was good, as well. I also hold a spot for Nadia - I like the rocker chick, I guess.

Anyway, my predictions:
Bottom Three: Anthony, Scott, and ???Jessica???
Going Home: Anthony <--he was in the bottom three last week (showing a seeming lack of support) and he didn't do that well tonight. However, I could easily see Scott (Scary Scott is his nickname in our house) getting the boot as well.

RyMickey
 
Here's my final vote, based on tonights performance only....

Vonzell
Constantine
Carrie
Nadia
Bo
Jessica
Nikko
Anthony
Anwar
Scott

I think they should add another vote to the show... Guess Paula's drug of Choice!! Ooo let's do a poll!
 
Ok...everyone hold onto your hats. I agreed with Simon tonight, Constantine was better than Bo! I did have to close my eyes while he was singing because I can't stand the faces he makes. I wasn't all that crazy about his singing still, but it was better then last weeks.

My picks: #1 and down

Carrie
Vonzell....where did that voice come from?
Nadia
Nikko
Jessica
Scott
Constantine
Bo
Anthony
Anwar


My prediction for bottom 3: Jessica, Scott, and Anthony

Going home? no guesses yet.
 
Octoberbeauty said:
You think Constantine is fat? :confused3 I can see him not being your "type", but fat? :confused3 I don't get it.

his face just looks big and blubbery to me....sorry. to each his own i guess
 
palmtreegirl said:
06-Nikko-His dad was a professional baseball player?! I really liked him tonight. LOL, my DD(8) said she wants to marry Nikko.

yup, his dad is Ozzie Smith.


Does anyone have Verizon? Have you been able to get through? This is the second week I haven't been able to get through for anyone so far, it just rings and rings and then james earl jones tells me my call cannot go through. :sad2:
 
Palmtreegirl, you have me rolling with laughter here on the Paula rehab comments. DH and I have been making those same comments! :rotfl:

O.K., I agree with those of you who think Vonzell had the performance of the night. She was simply incredible.

Also, for the first time since the competition began, I could see all the hype about Carrie. She also was fantastic tonight. I always love Nadia, even last week when the judges told her she was terrible, and she did not disappoint me tonight. I agree with Simon in that Jessica does not have the likeability factor going for her, for whatever reason. I have not been able to put my finger on it....she's very pretty and seems very sweet, but she doesn't do anything for me when she performs.

My favorite of the guys was Constantine, followed closely by Bo. I'm totally with you again, Palmtreegirl, in that I want so much to like Anwar, but I'm liking him less and less. Nikko was a lot of fun tonight, he's got the fun factor down to a science, but he's not as versatile as the others. I thought I thought Scott did a great job tonight, he truly has the voice of an angel, but he's just so stiff. And then there is Anthony, who is a nice looking guy, but has no umph!

I think Anthony, Anwar and Jessica will be in the bottom 3, with Anthony going home.

Overall this season, my favorites, in order of preference: Bo, Constantine, Nadia, Vonzell, Anwar, Carrie, Nikko, Jessica, Scott, Anthony. My order has changed a bit since the season first started, it began with Anwar very much at the top. Hope he can get himself back up there, because he's without a doubt my favorite from a personality standpoint.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top