Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[CookieGVB]

Wow - I actually LIKED Constantine tonight.

 

[JoenAdamnErinnSam]

ooooo..Constantine..loved it

 

[Philadisney]

WOW nadia was great! though I love melissa etheridge i'm not a big fan of that song, but nadia just nailed it. she has my vote....constantine was the first person tonight to sing a song i actually like, he did it well, he might be growing on me....like a fungus. i don't see myself placing any votes for him any time soon though. i was cracking up while he was trying to look all sexy by gazing wistfully into the camera while singing a pining love song, cos he is so fat and ugly to me....no offense to those of you who find him dreamy, i'm sure lots of people think anthony is ugly i think nikko was really improved tonight as well, though that's not really a type of music i like

 

[drgnfly30]

Nikko - started weak, got a bit better - definately NOT my cup of tea. Sit down Paula!

 

[wvjules]

I was not really a Nikko fan until tonight. But I'm still pulling for Jessica, Bo, or Carrie.

 

[J.Cooper]

WOW Nikko!!! Now that actually was refreshing. He did another good job tonight. I'd say one of the best performances thus far.

 

[Philadisney]

ok i take back what i said about anthony....without his glasses he kind of looks like one of the Peanuts characters. and what is that outfit?...doesn't help that, despite being an elton fan, i HATE this song.
poor anthony. i think he might be the next to go

 

[wvjules]

I think this was Anthony's best performance. First time I was impressed with him at all.

 

[CookieGVB]

Great ending. Check out the shirt - think he's a DIS member?

 

[RyMickey]

I don't even think Nadia was great tonight, but she's the best so far.

Constantine - Scary...and that "call me" thing that he does every week annoys the heck outta me.
Nikko - he couldn't hold that note at all at the end.
Anthony - wow - awful.

Paula needs to not like somebody, too. I can't stand that she likes everybody!

 

[drgnfly30]

Anthony - consistent vocals but I can't see him going much farther.

 

[disneyworldgirl]

6. Nikko-- "Can We Talk?" -- Very good tonight! I think Nikko showed why he deserved the second chance that he got (though I was sorry to see Mario go).

7. Anthony-- "The Way You Look Tonight" -- Good song choice, and he's showing some energy tonight (maybe it has something to do with the fact that he's not wearing his glasses!). Terrific vocals.

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Paula needs to not like somebody, too. I can't stand that she likes everybody!

She's like a mom to all of them--she won't pick one over the other--EVER. It's hard for her in the first rounds to actually tell someone that they do stink...she has done it on occasion, but not often.

 

[drgnfly30]

Someone started another thread that brought up Paula's, uummm current state of mind... hmmm what's really in those Coke cups?!

 

[J.Cooper]

Anthony was just ok for me. I think it was a safe song. Still think Nikko & Nadia are the best so far tonight.

 

[CookieGVB]

Standing ovation for Carrie - that girl can SANG!!

 

[Octoberbeauty]

while singing a pining love song, cos he is so fat and ugly to me....no offense to those of you who find him dreamy, i'm sure lots of people think anthony is ugly

You think Constantine is fat? I can see him not being your "type", but fat? I don't get it.


Go Carrie. You Rock!!

 

[drgnfly30]

Carrie - Great vocals but still bit too country for me - I guess "I'm a little bit Rock n Roll"

Even if she doesn't go all the way, I'm sure she'll do well in that genre.

Christine

 

[orangeblossom]

Constantine and Carrie were awesome.

 

[wvjules]

Scott is singing one of my favorite songs....btw, I'm gonna go download it right now while I'm thinking of it.