Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[macraven]

i have three faves....bo, constantine and scott.

scott has my heart, he needs family and has none but his fans.


yes to the op about scott last night.
when each candidate was over, the camera would pan to the family and relatives and friends for that singer.

at scott's turn, no papa or any wording for the viewing audience to show support from scott's relatives/friends. now that is sad.......

also, on the idolonfox.com board, scott talks about his son and how he is the father to him first.

 

[Cookie55]

Count me in on being an Anwar fan! Regardless of the official outcome, he will always be MY American Idol!

Next fave is Nadia, then Constantine, Jessica and Vonzell.

Bo is too "one note" for me.... he always sounds the same and does basically the same performance.

Carrie is too "country-fied" and can't seem to break away from doing everything that way... she also slides into her notes, instead of hitting them straight on... that is a HUGE turn off for me. She also lacks personality.... kind of like butter on white bread.

THANK YOU!!!! I couldn't agree with you more!! Anwar has the ability to do original renditions of his song choices, whether you like those choices or not. Carrie and Bo both lack in that department. I'm sooooo tired of Carrie getting a free ride (from Simon) evidently due to her marketability as a country singer. She takes no chances and other than a pretty face, completely lacks the "it" factor. ANWAR RULES!!!!!!!!

 

[Planogirl]

Bo "sounds" the same because he is a Rock singer. He doesn't do Pop or R&B like the others usually do. I'm personally extremely tired of Pop and would love to see someone a bit edgier come out as the winner.

 

[totalia]

Bo "sounds" the same because he is a Rock singer. He doesn't do Pop or R&B like the others usually do. I'm personally extremely tired of Pop and would love to see someone a bit edgier come out as the winner.

I so completely agree.

 

[Poohbear123]

I am a Scott and Bo fan after last night!

 

[Liz]

Do you think the judges know ahead of time who is getting voted off or do you suppose they find out when everyone else does?

I wonder if tonight they'll go back to having the person who is leaving sing again.

I hope Mikalah is going but I'm guessing it'll be Lindsay.

 

[Emme]

Mykalah-- I hate her. yeah I know she is 17 and hate is a strong word. I HATE HER. You know when you see people dress like that typically the conversation goes, 'why does so and so dress like that' answer: ' because she can'. Well.... She can't! did I mention I HATE HER?

Oh My! You had me rolling on the floor
I feel the same way about her. I mean what the heck is that girl and her mother thinking? This is American Idol, get it, an American people can idolize. HELLO!! Not my idea of an idol. OK I sound so mean, sorry BUT I still think she needs to go home NOW

 

[EpcotKilterFan]

Scott is from my area and each week the local Fox affiliate is at their house. There are alot of family and friends supporting him.

I believe his parents are going out for tonights show. His dad has never flown before. His mom was doing an interview with the local station while on the phone voting for Scott!

He was a security guard at Home Depot before this.

I like him and hope he makes it to the next round!

Debbie

 

[StaceyA]

Scott is from my area and each week the local Fox affiliate is at their house. There are alot of family and friends supporting him.

I believe his parents are going out for tonights show. His dad has never flown before. His mom was doing an interview with the local station while on the phone voting for Scott!

He was a security guard at Home Depot before this.

I like him and hope he makes it to the next round!

Debbie

HI there!
Thanks for the info! Was there any mention of what he told the judges his father said to and about him?

 

[EpcotKilterFan]

HI there!
Thanks for the info! Was there any mention of what he told the judges his father said to and about him?

Basically that he would never amount to anything. Scott has said that they have not had a very good relationship for a long time. The father is very supportive now. I think he may realize that he was wrong.

Scott and his father look ALOT alike. He also has a brother (I assume this) that looks exactly like him. So maybe they will show the family tonight

Debbie

 

[Cindy B]

I'm sorry, Scott doesn't do a thing for me. I am a former Shaker Heights resident, and he doesn't seem to fit the tony, affluent Shaker crowd. (Unless hes from the Shaker Square/Chagrin/Lee area-right on the border of the city)

I dont think he sings anything but R & B well. In fact, I thought his rendition last night was an almost repeat of sugar pie honey bunch which was a 2nd repeat. He's kind of boring.

 

[macraven]

it's about 4 minutes to count down time.


everybody have their tv on now?? !!!

 

[6_Time_Momma]

also, on the idolonfox.com board, scott talks about his son and how he is the father to him first.

Wow. I didn't know Scott had a son. Does it mention how old he is? Is Scott still involved with the mother? (just curious....not looking to condemn, just in case anyone is thinking that! )

 

[macraven]

i think it is wonderful that scott is putting his son first over him.

he loves that kid

 

[Philadisney]

i think it's goodbye lindsay.....can't say i'm sorry....
hmmmm, the bottom 3 tonight are all women. interesting

 

[lewdyan1]

i think it's goodbye lindsay.....can't say i'm sorry....
hmmmm, the bottom 3 tonight are all women. interesting

Great guess...She's gone.

 

[macraven]

hmm, do you think lindsay lost by three votes..........jk

don't flame me but i think mikalah was a tad better than lindsay last night.

but her time will come rather soon.

 

[Philadisney]

unfortunately i had to work late last night and missed the show. after seeing lindsey perform tonight though, i actually really enjoyed her (for the first time). i have no idea who is going to go next week - i guess maybe nikko, anthony, or mikaylah.....

 

[Emme]

NOOOOOOO!

I was so sure it would of been Mykalah. Oh well I can go to bed now. My whole sense of justice has just been shaken. Maybe she'll go next week

 

[Tina]

Ok AprilGail2. I think we're going to have to ban you from voting again until Micalah (I don't know how to spell her name!!!) is gone!!! Its all your fault!!