Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[sweet angel]

It surprises me that noone really ever mentions anything about Josh Gracin from last season, but he's doing really well in country music.

 

[damo]

I think because Josh was from two seasons ago, he has been overshadowed by last season and now the new season.

 

[Yzma and Kronk]

My least favorite? That Mikayla girl. My god, get that girl something for her hyperness! She's such a drama queen, and her voice is awful. She'd make a good comedien, but she's painful to watch.

This is so true!

Remember when Simon said that 50% of the people would love her and 50% would find her annoying. He was right! I got into a AI discussion the other day and the guy I was talking to loves Mikayla. I guess I'm in the second 50% - irritating!

 

[eeyore0062]

Originally Posted by ChrisnSteph
"My least favorite? That Mikayla girl. My god, get that girl something for her hyperness! She's such a drama queen, and her voice is awful. She'd make a good comedien, but she's painful to watch."

She is the next Fran Dresher!!!! I don't think she belongs in this competition and I really have to wonder about the judges for letting her get this far... she must give good hugs, or something???

Perhaps Judd isn't Latino, he just has a Latino/Italian look to me. I wasn't trying to imply a prejudice... I just thought it was kind of strange... I had forgotten about Mario, who is really good, too.

The girl from the country is good, but I noticed on Monday when the guys performed she didn't clap for any of them even once. That was kind of a turn off for me.

You are right, the girl I like is named Amanda.... I think I am trying to keep up with all of these reality shows and it is getting to me!

I have heard that Josh Gracin is out of the Marines and got a recording contract in Nashville, so he is doing pretty well for himself.

 

[Tasha+Scott]

Perhaps Judd isn't Latino, he just has a Latino/Italian look to me. I wasn't trying to imply a prejudice... I just thought it was kind of strange... I had forgotten about Mario, who is really good, too.

It is possible that Judd has Italian in him, b/c I have a similar look to him...dark hair and dark eyes and I am Italian. Although I did once have someone ask me if I had Latino in me so perhaps others think that is a Latino look. But anyway, my great-grandmother was full-blooded Italian and had blonde hair and blue eyes so you can just never tell, I guess.

I have heard that Josh Gracin is out of the Marines and got a recording contract in Nashville, so he is doing pretty well for himself.

Yes, I really enjoy country music, which is part of the reason I am rooting for Carrie. I didn't really like Josh during the AI season he was on. But I have really enjoyed the hits he has had on the radio this year. He is doing pretty well, that's for sure.

 

[Shugardrawers]

Anyone else think Joe Murano looks like a young Armand Assante?

 

[CarolA]

Well, I agree with Simon on him, he sounds like a lounge act. That kind of half voice falsetto! YUCK!

Josh and his Wife (?)have moved to Nashville. There have been reports of him in the paper.

 

[grinningghost]

Anyone else think Joe Murano looks like a young Armand Assante?

Yep.

But OMG, Anwar - he is so awesome! If he isn't THE AI, I want him to come to my house and personally serenade me.

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Not wowed just after the first three so far.

 

[Flyfly_Eclipse]

Originally Posted by ChrisnSteph

I have heard that Josh Gracin is out of the Marines and got a recording contract in Nashville, so he is doing pretty well for himself.

yup! he's going to be performing at Cypress Gardens too (if he hasn't already...forgot the date). He and Clay were my faves from season 2. Mario and Anwar are my faves this time around...

 

[Pugdog007]

Constantine is horrible tonight. He is so off pitch... and the screaming isn't helping.

 

[grinningghost]

Constantine is horrible tonight. He is so off pitch... and the screaming isn't helping.

I also thought he was off, but hey, the ladies like him. He'll get votes if he comes out and sings Mary Had a Little Lamb.

 

[JennyMominRI]

I'm not impressed yet

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Constantine is horrible tonight. He is so off pitch... and the screaming isn't helping.

He's sounding worse every week.

 

[Octoberbeauty]

I'm not impressed yet

Me either. Everyone is "good" tonight, but no one is "great" yet.

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Check Scott out---getting a style makeover there..and on his blurb clip--his eyes/face look like they are less sunken in and less of that bee sting in the face appearance. Is it just me? I think he looks less scary looky than the past (not that I thought that--but based on what others have said). I hope he keeps it up!

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Oh my--props for Scott from Paula and Simon agreed!!! (and Simon agreed with my assessment of a good appearance!!!). WOW!!

I agree with Paula and Simon

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

All Night Long--was a little too long for me...shaky! Is he talk-singing?

 

[CarolA]

Where are these men finding these songs??? And so far I am going for Anwar and no one else.

This is suppose to be the best group of men yet????

 

[grinningghost]

Travis worked it out for me! I think he's got it goin' on and I do hope he's given another week.