Offical American Idol Discussion Thread

[FOJMO]

OK, it must run in the family, because Noel's brother, JESUS, was also TERRIBLE!

Neither one of them can sing on key...

 

[antkim]

This is AWFUL!!!! How the **** did ANY of them make through this far? The judges should be getting an earful right now as well! I should be up there at least I can sing on tune!! Just a few years too old! LOL

 

[laurenk]

This is bad so far. Not really fair how the first two groups are so extremely different talent wise.

 

[cheeringmom]

The Quiznos hamsters sing better then most of the contestants so far. What has happened?? I never really liked the brothers from the beginning and they proved me right tonight. Poor guys

 

[musicalSaranader]

It's not the judge's faults. They all did very well in the past, but, I mean, there must be a curse tonight, because all of them are so bad tonight! Except the redhead, she was ok.

 

[karebear1]

Based on all your comments so far- should I even bother with watching it? Maybe it'll be good for a laugh or two!

 

[Popsicle]

YIKES!!!! Another one bitees the dust. Am I missing something with Camille's voice?

Based on tonight's performances, they should take ALL the contestants from last week and put them in the finals.

At least we can look forward to next week!!!

 

[antkim]

The scary thing is it's not even funny! It's dreadful! At least the "She Bang" guy was funny!! Oh no it's back on.....

 

[torismom]

Everyone was horrible tonight.I am so surprised at how awful everyone was.

 

[FOJMO]

At least I could pick two pretty good singers from the bunch -- kind of the best of the worst --

Matthew & Lisa

And that last girl looked like she was squatting to go to the bathroom or something -- even Simon said something about her stance.

 

[musicalSaranader]

Yeah I didn't like that last girl's posture either. I'm going to vote for Lisa tonight. Overall, I was so disappointed with tonight's group. I'd been hoping originally for Matt and Brianna, but they both disappointed me. Who're y'all voting for?

 

[JenBlaze]

The only one who shined at all was Lisa Leuschner.

Not to mention that I really wanna see her go far as payback for Simon's stupid weight loss comments. (Yeah, I'm bad.)

And I don't know what was freakier - "I wanna make Simon's head bleed" or "Simon's so sexy it's intimidating".

 

[Manda1219]

 

[cheeringmom]

Originally posted by karebear1
Based on all your comments so far- should I even bother with watching it? Maybe it'll be good for a laugh or two!

Sorry!! But you really should watch. You'll be in for a big surprise

 

[karebear1]

cheeringmom- I'm thinking you just want someone to share the pain with. Am I right? If that pic of "SHe bangs" is any hint to how bad it is tonight (People fantasizing about this guy's singing ) then I'm really afraid to watch!

 

[TwinMom7]

Last week's group was so much better, but I voted for Matt tonight. Considering the rest of the bunch...he was as good, if not better than anyone else....but that's not saying much tonight.

 

[damo]

That was unbelievably awful. Those kids from the first group must be feeling pretty good about their wild card chances now. I was expecting better from Bri and was disappointed in her performance. They all seemed to be terrified and had so little stage presence. I was thinking that maybe they couldn't hear the music properly or something the way they were all off-key.

If I had to vote it would be with Matthew and Camille. (#1, #7)

 

[2bemarried]

OMG that was HORRIBLE!!!! I was looking forward to seeing Matt and Brianna. Matt's ego and that comment about simon added to his singing made for a huge NOT getting my vote tonight moment. Brianna should not be singing Nora Jones songs. I'm actually happy that the twins did terrible..don't like either. Hawaii 1 girl scared me.
If I were being held at gun point and had to vote for two of them it would be Lisa and Marissa. None of them got a vote from this house tonight. Hope group 3 has something better to offer us.

 

[ValerieK]

I agree, tonight was awful. I was disappointed with Matt, I really like him. I thought Lisa was the best.

Why is everyone picking such bad songs? Does anyone else think that the sound is bad? Why aren't they piping the sound through the soundboard? You can barely hear them sing.

 

[karebear1]

OK- I'm 3 deep into listening now... and I have to say

They're dropping like flies!