I need some planning help, and hope those familiar with NYC can help. We arrive for our
ABD 2 nights early and when I made the reservation they would not let me add 2 nights at the Manhattan Club. I can book it on my own but then I guess would have to go through a check out/check in process before the adventure, which I guess starts pretty early in the morning. Another wrinkle is the day prior I plan on visiting Ellis Island and seeing Newsies. It looks like the theater Newsies is at is pretty far from the Manhattan Club, so I was thinking of getting a hotel close to that for the two nights and then moving to the Manhattan Club early the morning of the adventure.
What do you all think? Is the Manhattan Club walkable from Staybridge Suites Times Square (340 W 40th..the Manhattan Club is 200 W 56th) and if not how hard is it to get a taxi? Or would it be easier to just stay at the Manhattan Club and take a taxi if needed before /after the show, and again, how hard is that to do?
Also, will not be comfortable taking the subway, so what's the best way to get to the boat for Ellis Island? Is there a tour company or something who includes Ellis Island in their tour?
Any advice appreciated.