One benefit that I love about MP is that you will know in advance if a pulled-FP is no longer available (like when a ride breaks down), then you have the option of using your FP elsewhere. And you don't have to walk all the way to the ride to find out you can't use your FP.
I agree with all that you said except the above. If a family decides to skip Maxpass during their visit to save the money but still have their smartphones and data in the park, they can use the app to scan in the tickets and see the status of each of the Fastpasses they hold (regardless of how that Fastpass was booked, through Maxpass or at a kiosk). They could then use their phones to scan into rides, check return times and, most importantly, find out if and when a pass has converted to a “multiple experiences replacement fastpass” (or whatever they call it these days) due to the ride being down during that Fastpass’s return time.
Given how harder you have to work for your Fastpasses the traditional way, knowing that you can now use it during the afternoon or evening, when it’s increasingly harder to get Fastpasses for the rides you want, is of course an incredibly valuable piece of information for any performance tourer!
Another thing I found out on this most recent (non-Maxpass) trip, which is of very little practical value but incredibly fascinating for a system and numbers geek such as myself: there is actually another way (besides using a multiple experience pass that is no longer directly associated with the ride from whose Fastpass it came) to bypass the iron rule of THOUGH SHALL NOT EVER HOLD TWO FASTPASSES FOR ONE RIDE AT THE SAME TIME. My kids are fortunately used to nerdy me giving them sudden, seemingly odd instructions to “guys, humor me and do XYZ, so we can see what happens... please... for science!”
What I found out in this most recent experiment is that the system actually allows you to draw another Fastpass for the SAME ride (usually a big no-no) if the old one expired without your having used it. If you do so before the 15 mins grace period has ended and then use the expired pass by scanning it from your phone during that grace period to ride the ride, you actually turned yourself into that rarest of all Disney creatures, those who were once temporarily holding two Fastpasses for one ride at the same time!!! You can then use the newer, non-expired one and ride the ride again right after that.
We did this with Incredicoaster. I didn’t try it both ways but have a hunch that this only works if you scan your expired pass using your phone (as opposed to using your ticket for scanning) and that the scanner would have simply scanned the current, new Fastpass if I would have scanned into the ride using our tickets.
There are if course little to no real practical applications or uses for this revolutionary discovery besides it being kind of cool and deserving of major Fastpass nerd street cred of the “has boldly gone where no man had gone before” sort...
