Hmm, that seems pretty equivalent to what I was given in my PIN code for
free dining. $472 per adult for 4 nights in value room, 4 day base tickets and the quick-service plan which is only what...$30/night. Really if you do the math, we got basically the same offer.
What was the gift card offer that people got?
$418 sounds pretty decent to me but being near a major hub, you probably can find good deals more frequently than I can. I have priced out flights before and found driving to Minneapolis would save hundreds of dollars. When you factor in the drive to Des Moines (an hour from here), the time spent flying to a hub and layover time, driving to Minneapolis (less than 4 hours) would be about the same time commitment to get a cheaper, and direct flight!
We do have Allegiant Air which is direct and decent priced but only flys into Sanford so you either have to take a taxi (I once priced out close to $100 each way) or rent a car (which is what we did last year but we would have needed one anyway, just going to WDW probably isn't worth it)
I say drop her, I admit, I don't know who she is either!