So either someone dropped the ball and missed the part of BLT closing and gave them refurb money anyway, or something else is up.
This is speculation, but based on what is known for sure along with some educated guessing, here's what probably happened. Back in 2012 they were all set to do a pretty big overhaul of DHS which would include a major Carsland presence. Then suddenly (or at least pretty quickly) Disney bought LucasFilm. Around that same point, the powers that be decided that (a) they weren't ready to spend the money on a big DHS refurb that year and (b) IF they were going to spend the money - it damn well would be focused on Star Wars, which at that time wasn't ready to go into construction mode.
So, basically the folks at TDO were told to hold off on the capital build and WDI went back to the drawing board. So, they probably had already planned to refurb the trams in 2013 (with 2013/2014 budget money) so they went ahead and did it. At the time they did it, there was not yet approval for this big project that appears to be a go now.
Why did the Backlot Tour get closed as early as it did when construction was yet to start? Again this is all speculation, but it goes along with how a typical business like Disney runs.
- They knew in 2015 Annual plan they were going to shutter this ride for a major expansion.
- They also knew that this ride is fairly expensive to run and maintain (catastrophe canyon in particular), and is not very popular.
- By closing it down at the end of September 2014, they can basically cut the operating expense of this ride completely from 2015. Sure, they could've kept it running another 3-6 months, but knowing what is coming it just didn't make financial sense. They could cut budget here, which likely saved them from cutting operation budget elsewhere.
Based on normal business logic, closing the tram when they did makes perfect sense. This even could explain why American Idol was closed up. (Again, why spend money in a Fiscal year on an attraction that's closing anyways.)
The rest just seems very rushed with no real plan.
I am not sure how you can say this.
(A) they've only closed things, they haven't really started building anything.
(B) you (and I) have no idea WHAT the plan is.
rteetz likes to think some rumors hold more water than others because of who is saying them. Me, I take any individual rumors with a grain of salt, regardless of who says them. However, I consider the quantity of the rumors and combine that with the evidence of what is actually occurring.
To me, all these things point to the exact opposite of what you stated. There is a very specific plan for something to happen at DHS in the near future. That something is probably pretty big. That something almost definitely includes Star Wars. A major, major overhaul of the park is not something to take likely. DHS, while the lowest attended of the WDW parks, was never the ******* step-child that DCA was. And they TORE UP DCA. If they are doing a complete park overhaul, they need to really know exactly what they are doing so that they don't LOSE customers over the next 3-4 years, keeping as much of the park open for as long as possible. This is likely why an overhaul may occur in stages. Expand
pixar place first. Then when you have 2 or 3 new rides over there, you won't mind so much when they close these OTHER things over on this side of the park.