We've never eaten at Tony's. We weren't too impressed with Mama Melrose...but if you have a car...the places at Universal Studios' Portofino Have been very good in the past (haven't eaten there in over a year though), if a little pricey.
Last November we ate at a great restaurant called La Forchetta in Kissimmee (John Young Parkway). My sister's not particular about where she eats, and she was furious with me for driving past all the 'great' eateries on 192 to get there. When we arrived, it doesn't look like much from the outside, and I was nervous. We almost bailed, but we were very hungry, so we decided to give it a try. One step inside, and the aroma told us we were in for a treat! The food was EXCELLENT! The prices are reasonable for Italian food prepared by a family who cares. The service was excellent too. If you've got a car and get tired of the theme park atmosphere, this is well worth a visit. By the time we left, we felt like longtime friends of the owners. It's that kind of place.