I agree that many people will have the opportunity to return to WDW in the future, and therefore buying a 4-day hopper for a quick 2 or 3 day stay isn't a big deal. But there are people who either cannot afford to shell out money now for a hopper that's more than they can use, or, as in the case of 2 of my friends who are coming with me to WDW in October, they want to see bits and pieces of it once but might never come back. These friends don't live in the U.S., and usually vacation in Europe. They don't have kids, and are only planing to visit WDW because a mutual friend lives north of Orlando. Plus the shopping in Orlando is great compared to home. Basically, if we want to play for 3 days in the parks we either have to choose 3 out of the 4 and get one-day tickets (for aout $170 or so?) or they have to spend more than $200 for 4-day hoppers when they don't really know if they'll ever use the last day (and probably won't). I have told them that I will buy their last day if the 4-day hopper is ultimately our best choice (because we want all 4 parks, or want to hop), as I know I'll be back with my family in 3 or 4 years. The friend we are visiting is lucky in that she will likely be able to get a play 4 days pass if it comes out again for October, which will cost her about the same as 2 park days! We would be happy to get a 3-day hopper with expiry for us - it is the perfect ticket!! Why oh why is this such a big deal??!! I hate lying and conniving too, and I really don't want to do it. But t's frustrating having to choose between 2 options that really don't meet our needs. And if we go with the 4-day hoppers then I will be essentially prepaying for some of my future holiday when I buy the unused days from them - something I would have preferred not to do as this year is tight money-wise. I am only going on this girls trip because I have airmiles and free accomodation! Sigh
Anyway, I see all sides of this argument - I just wish there were a couple more ticket options, and I don't entirely understand why Disney has chosen not to offer them (except that maybe they want people to pay for future visits sooner by buying 4-day hoppers even if they don't need all the days now? Helps their cash flow, but hurts mine!).