Ever since I was a little girl and my parents were paying for the vacations, I have been eating around WDW. Since I got married, it's gotten worse. We plan on 2 big meals a day and we can barely walk by the end of the trip. My DH begs me to cut it down to one big meal and 1 small meal a day. We only go away every couple years (from now on, once a year) and so I get all of my dining out urges filled. So I've eaten almost everywhere several times each.
We are going in 2 weeks and I have a dilemma of cutting down my choices. IT'S SO HARD! This is what I do to help me decide so I don't keep going back to the same ones every time. I have a couple favorites like CG and YS, but I try to throw a few new ones in each time. Depending on where you are staying, try the resort restaurants. A lot of them are marvelous and you will be pleased you tried them. For example, when we stayed at the GF last time, we dined at V&A, Narcoosee's, the GFC and 1900. Then we took the monorail over to CG. We also dine at other resort restaurants depending where we are heading afterward. For example, we ate dinner at AP at the WL, then hopped a boat over to the MK for
MVMCP, then hopped the monorail home to the GF. The moderate resorts have some really nice options as well.
In 2 wks we are staying at the BWV and so I am going to try the restaurants over there. I am thinking of bagging CG and still going to YS, CM Cafe, Beaches and Cream, and then some EPCOT restaurants since I am so close to there like the Biergarten or Marrakesh (haven't been to those for YEARS and now would be a good time) or MGM restaurants like The BD (we try to eat there every trip). Remember that, although most are kid friendly, some restaurants are more entertaining than others. WCC at the WL, Hoop de Doo, O'Hanna, and the character breakfasts and dinners are great options for kids. Go to the ones near or at your resort. You'll get about the same experience from all of them.
So depending on where you are staying and who will be joining you, your choices can be made made more easily. But do get out of the rut and try a few new ones. You'll be pleasantly surprised!!! Hope this helps. Now back to my restaurant choices for 2 wks from now. Ha Ha!