Thinking about this a bit more, my preference really would be to see this go to advance signup like Pirates League or BBB. They would need to charge, to avoid high levels of no shows, but I would gladly pay a little extra for this and they could easily turn it into a "package" of some sort with things to keep, like a light saber or something. The mad rush from rope drop to the sign up was not anywhere near a magical experience, at all. To me, if they can find a way to avoid that, all the better. I just hope their answer isn't line up for an hour outside the gate, that's making it even worse, IMO. Plus, I really don't see that as a sustainable solution. If they went that way and once it became known, I think the line would become too much to manage in the turnstile/entrance area.