Thank you! I agree, a 5% discount before any stacking is easy to get so I consider that the baseline. Sam’s has had $200 DGC for $190 all year so they are my default. I buy them online and stack them with either a 5.25% BofA or Discover card.I cannot speak for others, but I find 20% to be a pretty hard number to get. I view it this way:
5% - Very easy to get. Sam’s Club $190 for $200 is the standard price. Target Red Card members get 5% off all the time.
10% - Watch for sales. They happen. Best Buy typically does 10% a couple times a year. They just finished yesterday. I believe it was also last year in February or March that they did it. This year the $450 for $500 “secret” sale was tantalizing because of how large the gift cards were… I wish I had learned about it earlier! Additionally Sam’s Club will provide a 10% off sale with some regularity - maybe 2 times a year or so $180 for $200. Typically there are supply limits for these types of sales.
More than 10% is pretty rare to find in a basic offer. Best Buy last year did a “drop” for I believe $80 for a $100 GC or something like that. It went within seconds, and was limited to 1 or 2 per customer.
Typically for the greater savings than 10% you need to double up. For example, last year the Sam’s Club May GC sale would be combined with the 5% cash back in wholesale clubs category at Discover. So you got 10% off plus another 5% back, making the total number relatively close to 15%. You sometimes can stack REDcard (Target) discounts with promotions that give you “awards” to use at Target.
Credit Card incentives often help, but can vary. Many individuals received Best Buy promotions on their American Express Cards this year. I have four American Express Cards, but none of them were eligible for the offer for me.
Your credit card, at a minimum should give you back 1% on what you are spending, which isn’t quite the same as 1% of the value of the card. So that is an additional bonus that people count towards it.
No Target Redcard and they seem pretty complicated to execute well but I know some folks here have figured it out to good effect so I am relooking at it. No Amex card either and you not getting Best Buy offers on 4 Amex cards seems like a sign to keep it what way.
With 3 BofA Customized Cash Reward cards and an Unlimited Cash Rewards card plus a Discover card I think I have cash back pretty well covered.
Where I still feel I am missing out when I read posts here is with credit card merchant offers. I took advantage of my first one only recently with a SW Chase offer at giftcard.com.
Thank you for sharing!