Narcoosee's vs. Boat house

[Kristi113]

For the few out there who have been able to try the new boat house restaurant in DTD, would you recommend that or Narcoosee's? We currently have reservations for both, but are only planning to go to one. We have been to Narcoosee's and loved it. Trying to decide if we should go back or try something new. Food and atmosphere/ambiance are both big considerations. TIA

 

[L&Lfan]

We have ADRs for both in November but if I HAD to choose one I'd choose the Boathouse. I love trying new places and having seen the menu online it seems larger with more offerings than Narcoossee's including some fabulous things you hardly ever see at Disney. Let us know what you decide...

 

[BuzzinDownToDisney]

Narcoossee's is by far my favorite restaurant in WDW, but if I could only choose one for our upcoming trip, I'd choose Boathouse, just to try it.

 

[snoopy352]

are you on the DDP or DXDP? If so, I'd go with Narcoossee's because it's on the plan and it's our favorite Dis restaurant. If not on the plan, I'd try BH for something new.

 

[JJZMgailey]

Narcoossee's is our most favorite signature restaurant - we had Christmas dinner there last year and it was fabulous! But, we have a rule in our family that every time we go, we try something new so we're eating lunch at The BOATHOUSE next week! I've heard rave reviews about so many things on their menu - can't wait to give it a try!

I vote that you give it a try too!!

 

[Megara5115]

We did both last trip and preferred Boathouse. Narcoossee's wasn't bad we just thought Boathouse food and value were better. We did have a Wishes time ADR at Narcoossee and were able to watch from the balcony which was great (also watched the Electric Pageant while waiting for our table). You can't go wrong with either experience but we liked Boathouse more.

 

[magicmomms]

I am still not able to get Boathouse Ressie for Oct., but I am in the same boat as you and decided on Boathouse...but can't get it~!

 

[mac3mpc]

We went to Narcoosee's last November for our anniversary and absolutely loved it. So much so that DH wanted a ADR there again this year. When I was able to get an ADR for Boathouse, I was torn. Both are 2 credit meals now for DDP. I couldn't decide either so we ended up moving things around and managed to fit both in.

 

[Kristi113]

I am still not able to get Boathouse Ressie for Oct., but I am in the same boat as you and decided on Boathouse...but can't get it~!

Call the restaurant directly. They have their own website with it posted. I could not get one through Disney, but when I called the restaurant I had no trouble getting exactly what I wanted.

 

[magicmomms]

Ok thanks!

 

[DisneyWishes14]

I've eaten at both (narcoosees twice) and Boathouse was by far the better meal.

 

[goofy4prez]

Narcoossee's is our favorite restaurant in Disney. We have an ADR for Narcoossee's next month and I called the Boathouse direct a couple of days ago and also have an ADR there as well. I shall see which one I like better.