I have been debating MNSSHP for the same reasons. Same questions apply.
At the end of the day I have to decide:
- Will I keep my expectations realistic? By that I mean that it is no good spending the evening there constantly trying to feel I have "got my money's worth for the evening".
- Remember that the US guest buy their tickets differently. The party tickets give you admission to the park as a park ticket from 4 pm, so effectively they have the option to benefit from not having to buy a park ticket for that day/use and admnission day from their multi day ticket. This will only work with UK tix if you go to the party on your first day BEFORE you activate your ticket or use it afterwards at the end of your trip if you will be there more days than what you have ticket days for.
- Has the hype generated by positive threads/reviews and recommendations damaged the reality of the experience by making my expectations too high?
- The park and attractions are the same as any other day. There s still a parade, but it is different. Characters are more plentiful and dressed up.
I would do it as a once off if DD really wanted to. She hasn't indicated any great desire to do so and I am happy to skip it for now on that basis. I would rather take the money and take her to a special dinner or get her a great treat or experience that we would not ordinarily do.
However I may go some time and love it and decide it is worth repeating. Not sure, but based on the foregoing, it is possibly not for us just now.