I like all of the mods, so my feeling is that you can be happy at any of them. POR-FQ is the most compact so if you prefer to minimize walking it might be a good choice. POR (dix landing) was recently renovated (this year) so that might be another good choice plus both POR locations offer boat service to DTD. CSR was renovated 2 or 3 years ago and is a conference facility so it offers extra amenities like a spa, work out facilities, several restaurants, a buffet, etc. and is the most centrally located to all parks of all the mods, so another good choice. CBR has the great pirate ship pool which is a kid's favorite - again, you really have some good picks. I personally would pick based on theme and amenities, since they are all about equal distance to Magic Kingdom by bus or car. If you want proximity to MK - you will have to step up to deluxe. You might consider Wilderness lodge. It is the least expensive of the deluxes, but offers boat service direct to MK. Would love to stay at any of them!!!