Excellent advice, Nic.
I'm thinking anytime from Friday (5/4) through the following Saturday (5/12) would be a good window to target.
Sorry Liz. I am terribly busy at work and went out to lunch today so didn't have a chance to post during my lunchbreak.
Yes. Good plan.
Why can't you? You already made your hey, how's it going call. You already know each other. Go ahead and ask if you want to.
See my previous comment about work.
Also excellent advice from PJ (and Michele via the phone).
Um, he probably did wonder why you called other than surely he sees that you were trying to make/reestablish a connection. That still doesn't meant the call went badly.
Yes, call him or talk to him in person. However, a note would be better than nothing. I still would urge the verbal communication though.
Some of my thoughts: as others have said Liz, it doesn't sound that bad. I know it wasn't how you pictured it but it was fine. He hasn't said no to anything so you are still in the game. Just call him again and do what Nic, PJ, and Michele suggested.
Address last night's phone call but do it with a sense of humor and don't act like it was a big deal. Tell him that it caught you by surprise that he had his kids over and that you then didn't want to be intrusive.
If you have small talk to make on this next call, fine. Make it and then ask for the date OR make the small talk and then say you'll call him again soon (and then on that call, ask him out).
If you don't have any small talk to make on this next call, just ask him out.
I doubt he's replaying the phone call in his mind. If he's even thinking about it, he's probably flattered that you called.
-- Rob