Maya Grill or Mama Melrose?

[heathjh]

I know Maya Grill changed their menu in Feb. So taking that into consideration which one is better? My DH loves a steak on a plate without anything else. So comparing just steak how does Maya Grill compare to Le Cellier?

Ok here is my situation with my dining dilemma. We will be at HS on Sept 25th. I have a res. at Whispering Canyon for 5:40. The transportation app I have says it's about 18 minutes away with wait normal wait times for the bus. I also made a Mama Melrose res. for dinner for that evening if I want to switch the WC res.

On Sunday the 26th we are going to Blizzard Beach. It closes at 5:00. I have a res. at Maya Grill at 6:15. Transportation app. says it is 10 minutes away. I was able to get a WHispering Canyon res. for 5:20. So to do that we would have to get out of the water at 4:00 instead of 5:00.

Which night should I do Whispering Canyon? And which is better Mama Melrose or Maya Grill?

 

[heathjh]

Anyone?? I would just like someones opinion.

 

[mjp12831]

Can only comment on MM - it was fine but that was because we did it with the F! package. The tomato sauce was fair to poor imo - apps and non red sauce dinners were ok but not exceptional.

 

[Mr. Disney 1986]

I enjoy Mama Melrose. It varies from entrée to entrée. I like their chicken parm, but do not care fore there steak.

 

[BEANTOWNDR7]

My family and I just did Mama Melrose's Fantasmic Dinner package and I have to say the food was incredible. My wife had the Grilled Chicken Flatbread Pizza while I had the Chicken Pipette. For dessert, we had the Chocolate Cannoli Cake (unbelievable) and Mama's Tiramasu but our waitress brought the Chocolate Amarettini Cheesecake. After noticing she made the mistake she brought the correct dessert so we had three magnificient desserts. I can't speak for the other restaurant you are undecided on but Mama's definitely has my vote. Good Luck