I look at this debate through the early-accelerator lens as well. But also as someone who thought running was stupid. As in, when my SIL suggested we run a HM together for her birthday in 2018 or 2019 I was like
hahhahahahha, NO. And then I went from (nearly) 0....I had fitness from other things, but definitely not running fitness to HM in 2021. I started running some during the winter on my treadmill and we signed up for one of the only available in-person races in the area, which was a trail run with 10-person staggered-start waves. And then I ran a marathon in October (that I talked SIL into....
for her birthday.) And then I ran Goofy in January was was kind of disappointed because I was
less than 10mi from getting ALL of the medals. And things very much snowballed from there and now I've done 3 Dopeys, am signed up for my 2nd Gooofy, bought
DVC because I hated depending on other people to book our rooms for race weekends, and signed up for a 50k.
When I got in for Goofy the first year (
and a LOT of all of this was very much influenced by these boards) runDisney was supposed to be a 1-and-done. The cut-off time is generous. There's a visual representation of the sweep line. The course is well-stocked for aid stations. If running a marathon is a "bucket-list" item for someone, Disney is a great way to do it because you can also make it a family vacation (with some allowances and planning.) And that's going to draw a lot of new runners year after year.
Whether or not people "should" be signing up for things is a whole different thing. We are not their doctors. And there
is a fair amount of gate-keeping when it comes to marathoning, although I do feel like it comes from a place of caring in a lot of ways....marathoners
tend to be experienced runners and know well the potential pitfalls and injuries, the time commitments, and the frustrations that can come with training. But there's not a perfect road, for the recreational runner, to the marathon. Slower runners tax their bodies in a different way than faster runners. Effort may be the same, but my can almost guarantee the forces on my body at 13:00min/mi are significantly different than someone who is running <8:00mi/mi.
And tying it back into registration (which is where the whole discussion started) there is no system besides this one that rundisney is willing to implement. There's no reason to. Registration is already like a lottery due to the number of browsers we all have open, and the sharing that occurs. Charities have waiting lists before registration day, or are often sold out the day after registration which is fantastic for them. Running
exploded in popularity during the shut-down, and now we're 5-years out from it and the number of people running doesn't seem to have waned. And that means more people have had the
opportunity to get eyeballs on one of our favorite things....which is marathon weekend.