SAFD: Count me among the picky feet club. I have narrow heels, a wide forefoot, a Morton's neuroma on my left foot, and Morton's toe (where the second toe is longer than the big toe) on both feet. FUN! After a lengthy search and much trial-and-error, I ended up in the NewBalance Fuel Cell line, training mostly in Rebels and racing in Elite V2s. When the first Supercomp trainers came out, I was super excited, but even with lacing tricks they flared my neuroma. Ugh.
Between changes to the FC line and my gait over time (I'm landing more midfoot and no longer heel striking), I've had to start over. I took advantage of a trip to Boston to pop into Marathon Sports and get a new eval and discovered another fun side effect of perimenopause: my feet are growing?! After finding my proper new running shoe size, we tried Brooks Ghost (good, not great), Altra (which I'd tried before and yep, still hate them), and finally Topo, which I'd never even heard of. I'm IN LOVE WITH THEM! They are built for my foot structure -- narrow heel, wide forefoot. I can actually tighten them up so the heel doesn't slip without squashing the top of my foot and flaring my neuroma. They don't feel huge like they are they are falling off, and I have just enough support and spring even though they are low drop (5mm). I bought a pair of Phantom 3 for most of my training and a pair of Atmos, which are a bit squishier, for my long runs. I'm hoping they hold up during training and one or both will be my Dopey shoes in January!