Both of these restaurants seem to get good reviews here at the DIS, so you probably would be happy with either. My personal experience has been that Tusker's food quality has been consistently good every time we have visited. I cannot say that about Flame Tree. Last time we ate at Flame Tree, I loved my BBQ chicken salad, but my DH's ribs were so tough they were actually inedible and he ended up throwing them. Each time we have been to Tusker's, we have had the pleasure of witnessing some wonderful African entertainment. We have seen a group ofCM's parade through playing musical instruments/singing, and have seen lone CM's go from table to table with interesting and spectacular attire and instruments. So, Tuskers gets the nod over Flame Tree for our family.