Luau vs Hoop Dee Doo Revue vs Mickey's BBQ

[maui2k5]

My GF and I will be heading to WDW Sept 22-Oct 1 and will be staying at the Swan. Two of the days while we are there we plan on going to Islands of Adventure and Universal. So we will have plenty of time to be in the parks at WDW. One thing I am considering is a dinner show. I used to stay at Fort Wilderness while growing up to going to the a show there would be fun. However, the Polynesian was the first show I ever went to back in the mid 1970's so I know that would be like old times also. Being that I have never been to the Hoop De Doo Revue or Mickey's Backyard BBQ and the Luau was about 30 yrs ago, I could use some help. Are the shows worth the money? If so, which is the best? I know there is Cirque De Solei in Downtown Disney, but I almost fell asleep at the last Cirque show I went to so that is not really on my list.

Any suggestions are appreciated!

 

[momo3hods]

I went to the Hoop Dee Doo last Thursday with my DH DD(4) DS(2) DD(7m) and my parents. It was my first time. What a great and entertaining show. The improv part was very well done. The food was great also, all you can eat including beer, wine, or sangria.