Lisa loves Pooh
DIS Legend
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2004
- Messages
- 40,449
Tough call. It is not mandatory to buy. And not mandatory to use. We always had the "option" because it came with the ticket. But we never used it. And we don't use it now. So I don't know where I stand on including in the comparison the cost of a feature that one does not have to have nor use. In the end, if a family is struggling to find a way to go to WDW and is pricing out the options, odds are they are going to skip the hopper option. So while this academic exercise may be invigorating, if we are really complaining about WDW becoming a country club, I choose to look at the problem as: what does someone have to spend to go there? And the answer would be the least expensive option. Remember, that back in the day, you only had the two original hotels. There was no "value" option. So in comparing prices today, do we compare only the Contemporary to the Contemporary and ignore the fact that someone on a strict budget could, if they chose, stay at Pop?
I am of the opinion they charge an extra fee since the ticket prices didn't go down when removing that feature.
But, I do know we used it in the mid to late 80s for MK and EPCOT, so I could not accurately compare my (well my parent's) costs without including the add-on.
As staying on site is not a requirement to enjoy Disney--what level hotels they have now compared to then is moot.
But my mom loved the price of our Poly concierge room rates in 1992. Somewhere near $200, though I don't remember exactly. (And if someone wants to correct from
Their memory if what it cost in July back then, be my guest. I am only going by what she told me as I did not see the final bill.)