My Maytag died about 2 months ago...so we had to replace it. We only had it for about 6 years, but it started just falling apart. The racks broke, pieces fell off, the tines in the racks started peeling and splitting...then, the electronics went. There was no way to know what cycle it was going to run through. The control pad was on the top of the door, so it was subjected to some heat and steam venting. Not sure it was a good design.
So, when I went to replace it, I asked our appliance repair guy what he suggesed. He said....Whirlpool, KitchenAid or Kenmore pretty much, unless we wanted to spend a ton of money.
We ended up with a very simple Whirlpool. I didn't want to spend the money for the stainless tub, so got a tub that is a greyish color that simulates stainless. It's supposed to resist staining to some extent. Also, you can't really move around the racks...they are what they are. You can move the top one up or down though. But, it has mulitple cycles. I love the Glass Express cycle. I use if for almost every load....we wash one load a day....so dishes aren't all that grimy and crusted. We also rinse our dishes before sticking them in the dw. That Glass Express cycle runs about 45 mins..total. The regular cycle runs close to 3 hrs!!! So, I run the full, regular cycle once a week, but otherwise, I use the shorter cycle. It isn't completely silent but it's a heck of a lot quieter than the old one.
I wanted a Bosch, but the repair guy said parts are hard to get for them and they do need work after a few years...at least in his experience.
Guess we'll see what happens.