My vote would be for the San Angel Inn followed Alfredo's. I can tell you there was a massive poll listing all the WS table places and Le Cellier won in a landslide.
I vote for Le Cellier for sure. Second voten for San Angel. Third vote for 9 Dragons. Our fav is Le Cellier and we tend to go here twice we love it so much. Never had bad food but sometimes service has been a little slow.
thanks everyone for your input we are going to eat at flying fish when we go to epcot (have gotten a lot of good reviews about that) have made ADR at prime time at MGM and have made one for California Grill at the contemporary Sat night