I’m so glad somebody else feels this way.
The last time I went to Disney I was planning a trip with my 5YO son. We used
Genie+ and it was fine, but I hated all the back and forth.
I was dreaming of VIP so we could just walk on when we wanted. And now I am planning a trip with a kid who will be 4 (and my son will be barely 8), and this option seems even better than VIP to me.
I don’t think my then-4YO could hang in a 7 hour tour, as much as I might romanticize it in my head. It’s too long with pressure to go go go and not take breaks for rest. She would be miserable by the end of it, and that means everybody else on the tour would be miserable too. And I’m with you, I also don’t want to spend our family time with some other person leading me around. This option lets us spread out some of the benefits of VIP over a few days instead of cramming it into one while being “guided.” The only downside is an inability to re-ride, but that’s a fairly limited trade-off IMO. The last time we were there my son didn’t care about riding things again, other than slinky. He just wanted to go on the next one as soon as he was off whatever ride he had just been on. He wanted to see everything because he had no real “favorites” yet.
The thing holding me back from VIP is the compact nature of it and forced socialization. It’s not the cost because we might go every 3-4 years and need to be efficient with our time. After our last trip I had all but decided to budget for VIP because I absolutely hated criss-crossing the parks and being on my phone all day. Husband and I will only go to Disney for the kids, not for us, and with limited vacation time we will slot it in as a 3-4 day trip. The time we spend there is very limited.
I am realizing that I am 100% the target audience for this: I have young kids, limited time, trips every 3-4 years, and the ability to budget for things like this with just a little notice.