We have never given the boys an allowance. They keep their rooms cleans, vacumm, clean their bathroom, clean up after supper, they will empty the dishwasher, the sink, the trash, they switch the laundry, put their folded clothes away, they sweep the floor, they keep their livingroom neat and tidy, these are things that make our house run smoothly. If I was doing all this, they would not be able to do all their extra stuff such as scouts, sports, refereeing, school dances, etc, because I would be so tied down with the household work I would not be able to cart them around to all their stuff.
The 2 older boys (12 and 14) referee soccer and get paid for that, but I take them there and keep their schedules. They also watch the younger ones occassionally, and while they do not get paid, they certainly get what they need and most of their wants. We all do firewood as a family, which is a lot of work and hardwork, but it is what keeps us warm for a low cost, having us being able to afford skiing with 5 kids during the winter.
We were just discussing what they want for Christmas and all 3 of the older boys were stumped and not think of a thing, which leads me to believe, we give them way to much of their wants.