We just finished our kitchen remodel. Our home is in NE Florida, built in '51, and we bought it from the original owner in '98. It REALLY looked like it should still be in the '50s, but things were "dingy."
My hubby's a builder, so he sees all sorts of countertops and sinks. This was helpful in making our "pro" vs. "con" list.
For us, our deciding factors were budget, appearance and maintenance. Our kitchen is full on retro '50s. Think Fonzie and Mel's Diner -- even have the black and white checkerboard floor. All these stone/aggregates just didn't match! I mean, it just seemed like everywhere we looked, your choices in color were: Black, light black, gray, beige, dark beige, light beige. I wanted color!
Even with DH's discounts, the prices were obscene, too. I'm sorry, but if I'm going to pay 10K for stone, it's going on my friggin' finger!
I took a Corian sample DH brought home and was able to scratch it with my fingernail. Eek! The maintenance associated with stone, plus that cost, put a big notch in the con column there.
The one that ended up winning was a high-end Formica! We picked the microdot finish, beveled edge upgrade, grasshopper for our color. It cost less than 10 percent what granite would have cost us.
We went with the biggest sink that would fit, lol. It's 9 1/2 inches deep, porcelain and a double. It's got a big curve on the left bin, up in the corner for your pots and pans handles to go into (this way, your entire pot fits in the sink!). My only regret is we got the soap dispenser attached in the sink itself. What a joke -- and a mess, as well. The thing leaks and is nearly impossible to refill. Our faucet comes out as a sprayer, too, so if I had it to do again, I'd just get a sleek look on the sink with a faucet only and buy a nice container for soap to keep on the counter or close to the faucet handles.
It wasn't that hard of a decision on the sink. None are perfect. We'd had stainless steel before, and they get these little pinholes in them. The porcelain gets marks easily from certain pots and pains. We paid less than $300, tho, and it was a depth that I wanted and double (I need to be able to dry my dishes on one side of my sink -- can't use countertop space for that).
Good luck! It's all about priorities, IMO, unless you're a millionaire.
Here's a few of our countertops. These were taken like our first night back in our kitchen, so it's not completely "furnished."
I can't resist posting this one here
This one below to hopefully capture the itty-bitty microdots?